Our proposal
A fix for the future
We want a solution that is fit for the future, not one that only answers the last election.
Not only a repair of the past
Voting rules are usually fixed looking backwards. Something goes wrong at one election, and the rule is changed to stop that one thing happening again.
Germany shows where that leads. Each of its three fixes answered the election before it, and each brought a side effect nobody had set out to create:
- Adding seats answered the overhang, and parliament grew: 631 members, then 709, against a planned 598.
- A partial brake was meant to slow the growth. It left up to three extra seats uncorrected, and parliament still grew to 736.
- Turning winners away answered both, and in 2025 left 23 electorate winners out of parliament.
Our rule is built to last:
- It is not tuned to one election. Each party’s votes in the House equal what its party vote earned, whatever the pattern of votes, the number of parties, or the size of an overhang.
- It has no numbers to haggle over. There is no limit of so many seats and no target size that the next Parliament must revisit.
- It does not create the next problem. The House stays at 120 votes, so the votes never grow. Every winner is seated, so nobody is left out.
No rule can foresee everything. What we can say is that this one holds by the way it is built, not by what happened in 2026.
Built for the Parliament voters are choosing
New Zealand needs a voting system built for a much more diverse Parliament, and ready for voters who use their voice in a much more nuanced way.
MMP’s way of balancing Parliament was designed for the politics of its time: two large parties, each winning about as many electorates as its party vote had earned. It works for as long as that holds.
Voters have moved on. They look for the voices in Parliament they feel represented by, and they find them across a wide range of parties. In 2026 the two largest parties together took 58.6 percent of the party vote, the lowest share since MMP began (preliminary count). In 1951 the two largest took 99.8 percent.
We call this vote splintering: over many elections, the party vote spreads across more parties. It is not the same as vote-splitting, which is one voter giving their two votes to different parties at one election.
The electorates have not moved in the same way. Each one still goes to whoever comes first, so the party that leads still wins about six in ten. When that party’s share of the party vote falls below about 35 percent, the list seats can no longer balance the House. In 2023 the leading party had five seats to spare. In 2026 it was seven short.
In 2009 Germany stood where New Zealand stands now. It has tried every remedy but one, and we can see how each turned out. We do not have to repeat them.
Our rule does not depend on any of this:
- If the party vote spreads further, the votes in Parliament follow it.
- If it gathers again around two large parties, no party wins more electorates than its party vote earned, every MP has a vote, and the rule is never needed.
Other rules work in one of those worlds. Ours works in both.
Entrenched, so that it lasts
A rule built for the future must also be able to stay. Today a bare majority of MPs could change how seats are shared out. A fix passed that way could be removed that way, by the next majority that finds an overhang useful.
So we want the fix entrenched, together with MMP as a whole. An entrenched rule can only be changed by three-quarters of all MPs, or by a majority of voters in a referendum. The term of Parliament and the voting age are protected in this way already. MMP is not.
Entrenchment does not freeze the system. It means that the rules of the game change only when nearly the whole House, or the voters themselves, decide that they should.
Entrenchment: what it is, what we want protected, and what it takes
A local voice at the centre, whatever comes
New Zealand is debating how local government should work. We take no side in that debate. But a voting rule made today should not close doors for tomorrow.
Germany offers a loose model. Its federal parliament does not stand alone: the states have their own say, and a constitutional court stands over both. That balance is one reason German governments have been steady. New Zealand has one House and no such counterweights, so who sits in that House matters more here.
Our rule keeps one thing fixed for the future. Each of the 71 electorates has its own MP in Parliament, chosen by its own voters, and we want that protected in law. However local and central government are arranged in years to come, every community keeps a guaranteed voice where the laws are made. Fixes that turn winners away, or that leave electorates to chance, cannot promise that.
The fix in five points · Why this is fair · Entrenchment · Non-voting MPs · Get involved