Save MMP!

In their own words

What people are saying

Since the election, people from across politics have spoken about the overhang. Here is some of what they said in public, with the source for each.

Quoting someone is not an endorsement. These are public statements. Those quoted have not endorsed SaveMMP.

On votes that follow the party vote

Some have proposed the same idea as ours: every electorate winner sits, and each party votes in the House with the votes its party vote earned.

“If there is an overhang you don’t take the seats off the party that has the overhang because those people in those electorates deserve to be represented, but what you do is you reduce the party’s vote in parliament to the proportion of party votes that it gets. … I think that would be a rather elegant solution to the problem.”

Phil Goff, former Labour leader and Mayor of Auckland. Cross Party Lines, 17 November 2026.

“We need only change the rules so that votes in the House are calculated on each party’s party vote alone. Overhanging MPs are simply not counted.”

Pete Hodgson, Labour MP for Dunedin North 1990–2011, on Parliament’s Electoral Law select committee 1990–99. Otago Daily Times, 17 November 2026.

“What it would do is completely remove the incentives for the kind of manipulative strategies that Te Pāti Māori used, and various people on the right were trying to use …”

Professor Jack Vowles, Victoria University of Wellington. Quoted in Stuff, 17 November 2026.

“… adjust the voting rules in Parliament so a party’s voting strength in Parliament is based on its party vote not its total MPs.”

One of four options in the experts’ open letter “Keep the ‘P’ in MMP”, signed by 46 electoral experts, 18 November 2026. The letter does not prefer any one option. Our summary of the letter.

On the problem

“The system as it stands is sadly prone to gaming from both the left and the right. And it has been gamed from both sides in this 2026 election.”

Sir Geoffrey Palmer, former Prime Minister. Newsroom, 14 November 2026.

“MMP was designed to see parties proportionally represented - yet in a dead heat party vote result, National currently has around 6 more seats in parliament.”

Helen Clark, former Prime Minister. Published statement, shown on ThreeNews, 9 November 2026.

“I think that is a real perversion of what MMP was supposed to be about.”

Gerry Brownlee, outgoing Speaker, on organised vote-splitting. Duncan Garner, 15 November 2026. How our fix keeps the spirit of the rule.

“The proportionality of MMP is now at risk.”

The experts’ open letter, 18 November 2026.

“The election’s most obviously distasteful element was the attempt by both left and right to engineer extra ‘overhang’ seats.”

Max Rashbrooke, senior research fellow, School of Government, Victoria University of Wellington. The Post, 14 November 2026.

The plan to engineer a National overhang would be “profoundly undemocratic”.

David Farrar, National Party pollster, before the election. Quoted in The Spinoff, 8 September 2026.

“Democracy belongs to all New Zealanders, and every vote should count equally.”

Marama Davidson, Green co-leader. The Post, 18 November 2026.

“Parliament should come together to amend our electoral rules to make overhangs impossible or at least less likely.”

Thomas Coughlan, NZ Herald Political Editor, before the election. NZ Herald, October 2026.

On the Māori electorates

We want the existence of the Māori electorates protected in law, with their future for Māori to decide (see Entrenchment). The first party to respond to the experts’ open letter said they must be protected in any change.

Any change must uphold Te Tiriti o Waitangi and protect the Māori electorates, which guarantee tangata whenua representation in Parliament.

Marama Davidson, Green co-leader, as reported by The Post, 18 November 2026. This is the newspaper’s report of what she said, not her exact words.

On TV

1News, “MMP makeover?”

On 18 November 2026, 1News at Six reported the experts’ open letter and the options for fixing the overhang. The story includes Lara Greaves of Victoria University, Green co-leader Marama Davidson, letter signatory Oliver Hartwich, voters in Wellington, and a look at Germany.

Watch the 1News story on TVNZ+Why the 2026 record election overhang has experts worried · 2 min 14 s

Opens on TVNZ+, TVNZ’s website, which may ask you to sign in. More coverage is on our Media page.

What MMP’s designers expected

“A similar effect could occur if a large number of voters ‘split’ their constituency and list votes. There is also a remote possibility that deliberate manipulation of the system could occur whereby 2 parties used their combined vote to gain a disproportionate share of seats. While these results are theoretically possible, the Commission considers that accidental deviations are most unlikely, and that any attempt to deliberately manipulate the system would be both difficult to implement and likely to attract an electoral backlash.”

The Royal Commission on the Electoral System, Towards a Better Democracy, 1986, paragraph 2.119.

In 2026 campaigns on both sides urged voters to split their votes. How far voters followed is not yet known: the Electoral Commission’s split-vote statistics are due by 14 December 2026.

We tolerate an overhang. We stop it from distorting proportionality.

See the fix