Save MMP!

Our proposal in detail

Non-voting MPs

An overhang gains only one advantage: local representation. This page sets out what that means for the MPs concerned.

In brief

  • Representation can be gained through the electorate vote. Voting rights in Parliament are derived from the party vote alone. An overhang seat is representation the party vote does not cover. It keeps the seat and carries no vote, because the party vote never earned one. Nothing is taken away.
  • If a party wins more electorates than its party vote earned, every winner still becomes an MP. The party’s votes in the House stay at what its party vote earned.
  • The winners beyond that number are non-voting MPs. They are sworn in, are paid as MPs, keep an electorate office and work for local people.
  • They take part in the work of Parliament through a select committee, in writing, and in their party. They do not vote in the House.
  • In caucus, all of a party’s MPs are equal, voting and non-voting. A non-voting MP takes part and votes there on every matter, including discipline.
  • A non-voting MP can gain a vote during the term. When a voting MP of the same party leaves Parliament, for example by retiring, the vote passes to the party’s next non-voting MP, in list order.
  • It is decided afresh at every election, and the voters can change it with their party votes.

This page describes our draft as at November 2026. It has not yet been reviewed by lawyers or by Parliament’s own experts, and one point is still open. We set it out below. For the exact wording, see the changes in law.

Who would be a non-voting MP?

Mainly an electorate MP whose party has won more electorates than its party vote earned. Three smaller cases sit beside it: an independent who stands in the electorate only, a winner for a party that declines the party vote, and an electorate MP who leaves their party. If none of these arises, every MP votes, as now.

On 2026 election-night figures there would be 11:

PartyElectorates wonVotes its party vote earnedNon-voting MPs
National42357
Te Pāti Māori514
All other partiesNo more electorates than their party vote earned0

These are election-night figures. The official results are declared on 27 November 2026, and this page will be updated then.

For Te Pāti Māori, whose MPs come from the Māori electorates, the effect is large. What it means for the Māori electorates, and what we have built in →

Which of a party’s MPs hold its votes?

The order of the party’s list decides, and the list is lodged before the election. The electorate winners who stand highest on the list hold the party’s votes. The rest are non-voting MPs.

Nobody chooses after the election. A party cannot move a vote from one MP to another during the term.

It is not permanent

  • During the term, if one of the party’s voting MPs leaves Parliament, the vote passes to the party’s next non-voting MP, in list order.
  • At the next election, everything is decided afresh. If more people give the party their party vote, more of its electorate MPs vote.

What they can and cannot do

A non-voting MP is a member of Parliament for every purpose except voting in the House.

SubjectWhat a non-voting MP can doWhat is kept for voting MPs
StandingTakes the oath. Has the same legal protection for what is said in Parliament as any other MP.
PayIs paid as an MP. The pay of MPs is set by an independent body, as now.
The electorateKeeps an electorate office and staff, and takes up local people’s cases with Ministers and departments.
The partyRemains a member of the party in Parliament. In caucus, all of a party’s MPs are equal, voting and non-voting. A non-voting MP takes part and votes there on every matter, including discipline. Our draft law says so.Being party leader or whip.
Select committeesHas a guaranteed place on at least one committee, which the MP chooses. There the MP can speak, question witnesses, move motions and record a different view in the committee’s report. The party cannot remove the MP from that place. The MP is appointed along with the committee’s other members. Parliament may cap how many non-voting MPs sit on any one committee, but every non-voting MP must have a place.Voting in the committee, and chairing it.
In writingCan present written statements and reports about the electorate to the House. They are published as papers of Parliament and sent to the select committee that deals with the subject, which must consider them and report to the House. There is no limit on how many an MP may present. Can put written questions to Ministers. Can propose a member’s bill jointly with a voting MP of the party; it counts as that MP’s entry in the ballot, and the voting MP takes it through the House.
In the HouseDoes not sit in the debating chamber. Has a permanent place in the gallery and may watch every sitting. Comes into the chamber to be sworn in, to make a first speech on arriving and a farewell speech on leaving, and to be heard on a particular matter: at least once a year as of right, and more often when the House agrees. Voting MPs may then put questions, and the MP answers.Taking part in debates as of right.
VotesEvery vote in the House, including conscience votes.
OfficesBeing a Minister or Parliamentary Under-Secretary, Speaker, Deputy Speaker or Assistant Speaker, Leader of the Opposition, or chairperson or deputy chairperson of a select committee. Voting for the Speaker.

Why conscience votes too?

Otherwise the House would have more than 120 votes on those questions, and an overhang party’s MPs would carry more weight than its party vote earned.

Why must a Minister have a vote?

Ministers answer to the House, and a government stands or falls on votes there. Parties can place the people they want as Ministers high on their list.

Where a non-voting MP has more than a voting MP

A non-voting MP gives up the vote in the House. In four respects our draft gives them more than a voting MP has today:

  • A select committee of their own choosing. A voting MP sits on the committees the party puts them on.
  • A place the party cannot take away. A party can move a voting MP off a committee at any time.
  • Written statements that must be answered. The committee for the subject must consider each one and report to the House. No voting MP can require that.
  • A hearing in the House as of right, at least once a year, on a matter the MP chooses. A voting MP speaks when the party and the Speaker give them the call.

These rights belong to the MP and not to the party. They are there so that an electorate whose MP has no vote is still heard, in the MP’s own words. It follows from our position that we strengthen the role of the non-voting MP wherever we can.

Money and staff

  • The MP is paid as an MP.
  • The electorate keeps its office and its staff. Every electorate gets this, whether or not its MP has a vote.
  • The party gains nothing. Money and staff for a party’s work in Parliament follow its votes, not the number of its MPs.

It costs no more than today’s rules, under which the extra MPs also sit and are paid.

What happens during the term

Each party’s number of votes is set at the general election and stays the same until the next one. The House has 120 votes throughout, with the one exception listed below: a party’s list that runs out.

  • A by-election. The electorate gets its new MP. If the winner’s party already holds all the votes its party vote earned, the new MP sits without a vote. A winner who was not on the party’s list at the general election joins it at the foot, and so stands last in line for a vote. An independent who wins sits without a vote. A by-election cannot shift the balance of Parliament.
  • A party’s list runs out. If a party has nobody left to take a vote, that vote stays empty until the next election, as an empty list seat does today. Parliament then has fewer than 120 votes for that time.
  • A voting MP leaves Parliament. The vote stays with the party. It passes to the party’s next non-voting MP, in list order. If the party has none, the next person on its list comes in, as now.
  • An MP leaves their party. Under our draft an electorate seat belongs to the MP, a list seat belongs to the party vote that filled it, and the vote always belongs to the party. An electorate MP stays in Parliament, as a non-voting MP for the rest of the term, and goes on serving the electorate. The vote stays with the party the voters gave it to. A list MP who leaves the party, or is expelled from it, leaves Parliament, and the next person on the party’s list comes in.

So a majority is 61 of 120 votes, however many MPs there are. Only a list that runs out can lower that number.

Has this been done before?

In part. Members of a parliament without a counted vote are an old and widespread arrangement. Our reason for it is new.

What is not new

  • United States. The House of Representatives has seated Delegates from the territories since 1794. They speak in debates and vote in committees. They do not vote on the floor of the House.
  • Australia. From 1922 to 1968 the member for the Northern Territory sat and spoke in the House of Representatives, with the same pay and standing as other members, and had no vote or only a limited one.
  • Germany. From 1949 to 1990 West Berlin’s members of the Bundestag took part in everything, but their votes were not counted in the result. Some led their parties in parliament or served as federal Ministers.
  • New Zealand. Parliament’s own rules already provide for non-voting members of select committees.

The record shows that such members did real work: in committees, in their parties, in writing and for the people they represented.

What is new

  • The reason. Elsewhere the vote was withheld because of where the members came from: a territory, an occupied city, a minority. Nowhere that we have found was it withheld to hold a party to its share of the party vote.
  • The change itself. Today these seats carry a full vote. We have found no case where elected members with a vote became members without one.
  • The debating chamber. Elsewhere, non-voting members could usually speak in debates. Under our draft they do not sit in the chamber. They have a permanent place in the gallery, and a voice in the chamber for their first and last speeches, at a hearing at least once a year as of right, and more often when the House agrees.

What the record warns of

Most of those arrangements ended with the members gaining a full vote, and where the members were elected, many of them resented the status. We take that seriously.

Three things are different here:

  • The voters are fully represented. In the other cases, the people who elected the member had no say in the votes of the House. Here every party vote counts in full, including those of the people in that electorate.
  • The status is temporary. It is decided afresh at every election, it can end earlier when a vote passes down the list, and the voters can end it at the next election with their party votes.
  • The rights are protected in law. Elsewhere, rights that rested on a parliament’s own rules were given and taken away by whoever held the majority. We want these rights written into the Electoral Act and protected in the same way as the rule itself.

Experience elsewhere cannot tell us how those three differences will work out. On these points we argue from principle, and we say so.

Germany chose a harsher answer in 2023: an electorate winner beyond the party’s share gets no seat at all. In 2025 that left 23 winners out of parliament. See Germany’s three fixes.

Sources: Congressional Research Service reports R40555 and R40170 (United States); Northern Territory Representation Acts 1922 to 1968 (Australia); Deutscher Bundestag, Datenhandbuch (Germany); Standing Orders of the House of Representatives 2026, “Non-voting members” (New Zealand). Our research on these cases will be published with our paper.

What is still open

We have not settled this point, and we want it debated:

  • A voice in debates. Our draft gives each non-voting MP the right to be heard by the House at least once a year. Should they also be able to speak in debates? Most other parliaments that have had such members allowed it.

Tell us what you think. Send us a message.

The fix in five points · The changes in law · Frequently Asked Questions · Dictionary · Get involved