Our proposal
Te Tiriti o Waitangi and the Māori electorates
Under our fix, votes in Parliament come from the party vote alone, and representation comes through the electorate vote. The Māori electorates and their MPs all stay. What changes is how many votes in the House those MPs hold. That is a real change. We think it should be made only with Māori agreement, and we have not yet asked.
In brief
- Every Māori electorate and every Māori electorate MP stays. We want the Māori electorates protected in law.
- The vote in the House follows the party vote, for every party alike. Where a party wins more electorates than its party vote earns, some of its MPs are non-voting MPs.
- It may fall harder on Māori. We set out below where, including turnout.
- Māori have not been consulted. This page is our analysis, not a Māori view.
What stays the same
- The Māori roll and the Māori electoral option.
- The seven Māori electorates. We want their existence entrenched, as the 2023 Independent Electoral Review recommended, so that a bare majority in Parliament cannot abolish them. Their future stays for Māori to decide.
- Every Māori electorate MP. Each one keeps their seat and serves their electorate.
- Every party vote on the Māori roll. It counts exactly as a party vote on the general roll does.
What would change
Today, a party that wins more electorates than its party vote earns keeps every one of those MPs, and every one of them votes in the House. Under our fix the party still keeps every MP, but it holds only as many votes as its party vote earned. The rest are non-voting MPs.
The rule applies to every party alike. On election-night figures it would make 7 of National’s 42 MPs non-voting, and 4 of Te Pāti Māori’s 5. For a party whose support comes mostly through electorate votes, the effect is large.
Where it may fall short
We set this out because the case against us deserves to be heard in full.
Fewer votes from MPs who answer only to Māori voters
The Waitangi Tribunal has said the Crown must provide Māori with representation sufficient to protect their rights and interests from the actions of the majority. Fewer votes in the House from MPs chosen by Māori voters alone is, on its face, less of that protection.
Equal rules, unequal effect
The Tribunal treats equity as real, not formal, equality. It has found a general electoral rule in breach where it fell harder on Māori. Our rule is the same for every party, but it falls hardest on a party built on the Māori electorates.
Turnout
Electorates are drawn by population. Today an electorate MP counts in full however many people voted. Under our fix a party’s votes in the House come from the party votes actually cast.
Fewer people vote in the Māori electorates. In 2020, 73% of voters of Māori descent voted, against 83% of everyone else. So the party votes cast on the Māori roll count for less than the Māori electorates’ share of the population: by about two to four seats of 120.
This already applies to every party’s list seats under MMP. Our fix extends it to the overhang, which is the one place where turnout did not count.
Those are past figures, not a forecast. Today, once a Māori electorate is won, more votes there change little in the House. Under our fix every extra party vote counts, which gives people a new reason to vote. If everyone on the Māori roll voted, the roll would carry about 15 of the 120 votes in the House, twice the seven Māori electorates. How Māori voters use that is for them to decide. Our part is to say plainly where the concern lies, and what we would do about it (see below).
Two ticks do not fully restore the vote
If every voter for a Te Pāti Māori candidate had also given the party their party vote, the party would have earned 4 votes in the House, not 5, at this year’s turnout. Turnout is part of the reason.
The party list decides
The party’s list, not the result in each electorate, decides which Māori electorates have a voting MP.
Voice as well as vote
Under our draft, non-voting MPs do not sit in the debating chamber. They have a permanent place in the gallery and are heard by the House at least once a year as of right. That limits voice as well as vote, and a party vote cannot give voice back.
What we have built in
We will not ask for the change on its own. It comes with protections for Māori, and without them it should not be made.
- Every non-voting MP keeps their seat, their electorate work, and their full place in caucus. In caucus every MP is equal, voting or not.
- Non-voting MPs choose the select committee they sit on, and can propose a member’s bill jointly with a voting MP of their party.
- Their rights are written into law and entrenched, so a bare majority cannot take them away.
- Every electorate candidate must be on the party list, so no winner is shut out for being unlisted.
- A non-voting MP from a Māori electorate can choose a place on the Māori Affairs Committee, whatever the limit on other committees.
- After every election the Electoral Commission reports, in public, on turnout on each roll, on the Māori roll’s share of the vote, and on how many MPs from Māori electorates hold a vote.
- After the first election under the fix, an independent review, carried out with Māori, looks at what it has done to Māori representation, and the Government must respond.
What we ask
Māori agreement. The change to what the Māori electorates deliver should be made only with Māori agreement. Who gives that agreement, how and when, is for Māori to say, not for us.
Make it far easier to enrol and vote. The Crown must make it dramatically easier for every voter, and specifically Māori and young voters:
- to enrol;
- to stay enrolled, when they move or their details change;
- to cast their vote;
- and above all in rural areas, where getting to a voting place can be the hardest part. Several Māori electorates cover some of the largest areas of any electorate; Te Tai Tonga covers the whole South Island.
No voter should ever drop off the roll because they moved. The Tribunal has said the Crown should take special steps to encourage Māori to take part in elections. For Māori voters, the measures should be designed with Māori. We think this is the answer to the turnout gap, not giving some votes more weight than others.
Māori as partners in the reform. A select committee hearing submissions is not the same as working with the Treaty partner. We ask that the Crown work with Māori directly before a bill goes to Parliament.
What is still open
- Māori have not been consulted. Until they are, this page is our analysis and nothing more.
- What follows if Māori agreement is withheld.
- Whether non-voting MPs need to be kept out of the debating chamber at all, when the aim of the fix is about votes.
- Whether these protections are enough, and which others Māori would want (see the other options).
- Whether fair representation under Te Tiriti is measured by the party votes of Māori voters or by the MPs their electorates return. The Tribunal has not decided this, and our fix may stand or fall on it.
Other options, and where we stand
There are other ways to protect Māori representation than the ones we have built in. Some have been put forward by others, and some Māori may well raise. Here is what each would do, and where we stand. Where we have not decided, we say so.
Leave the Māori electorates out of the rule
MPs from the Māori electorates would always keep a full vote, whatever their party’s party vote. This is the most direct protection. We have not proposed it, because a rule that applies to some parties and not others would keep the double weight of a split vote for one roll, and invite others to look for their own exemption. Germany exempts parties of national minorities from its 5% threshold, but not from the rule that party votes must cover electorate seats. If Māori ask for it, it must be part of the conversation.
Let non-voting MPs from Māori electorates speak in the chamber
Our draft gives every non-voting MP a permanent place in the gallery, not the chamber. That limits voice as well as vote. Letting non-voting MPs sit and speak in the chamber, either all of them or those from Māori electorates, would answer much of that. We have not decided.
An eighth Māori electorate
The number of Māori electorates follows the Māori electoral population. In 2025 the count came to 7.43, just short of the 7.5 needed for an eighth. Te Pāti Māori says the roll has since grown enough for eight. A Government bill would keep the number at seven until 2032; it had not passed when Parliament rose. We have not taken a position. Under our fix an eighth electorate would mean one more MP from a Māori electorate. Votes in the House would still follow the party vote.
Count Māori-roll party votes for more
Each party vote on the Māori roll would be weighted so that the roll carries its share of the population in the House, not its share of votes cast. On election-night figures each would count about a quarter more. We do not propose it: it would make some votes count more than others, and most of the benefit would go to the parties most Māori voters give their party vote to. But it is a real option for Māori to raise.
A separate Māori share of the votes in the House
A fixed share of the votes in the House would be shared among the parties by the Māori roll’s party votes alone. This also departs from equal votes, and is likewise for Māori to raise.
A Parliamentary Commissioner for Te Tiriti o Waitangi
Te Pāti Māori proposes an independent officer of Parliament to hold the Crown to its Treaty obligations. This is not our proposal, and we do not oppose it. If one existed, it could be well placed to carry out the review after the first election under our fix.
Wider constitutional change
Matike Mai Aotearoa, the 2016 report of the Independent Working Group on Constitutional Transformation, looks at constitutional arrangements based on Te Tiriti. That question is much larger than ours, and our campaign takes no position on it.
Fewer Māori electorates, or none
Some have proposed abolishing the Māori electorates, and some reforms would cut their number as a side effect. We oppose both. We want their existence protected in law, and their future left for Māori to decide.
What others have said
- Te Pāti Māori (19 November 2026) opposes two of the experts’ options, cutting electorates or denying winners their seats. It calls for an eighth Māori electorate, entrenchment, and Māori at the table as Tiriti partners in any review. Our fix keeps every winner in their seat.
- The Green Party (18 November 2026) backs a review and says any change must uphold Te Tiriti and protect the Māori electorates.
- The experts’ open letter asks the inquiry to consider New Zealand’s own constitutional arrangements, including Te Tiriti o Waitangi.