Where it came from
2023: the Independent Electoral Review
Ten years after the MMP review was shelved, an independent panel looked at the whole of New Zealand’s electoral law. On the overhang it reached the same answer as in 2012. It also asked for the rules that turn votes into seats to be protected from a bare majority in Parliament. When the 2026 election came, the overhang rule was unchanged.
The review
The Minister of Justice set up the Independent Electoral Review in May 2022, with a panel of independent experts chaired by Deborah Hart. It consulted twice, and more than 7,500 submissions were made. It published an interim report in June 2023 and handed over its final report in November 2023. The new Government released it on 16 January 2024.
Read the report: Independent Electoral Review: Final Report, November 2023 (PDF, 11.7 MB, Ministry of Justice). The overhang is discussed in Chapter 4, paragraphs 4.90 to 4.101, and entrenchment in Chapter 2.
Sources: Ministry of Justice, Independent Electoral Review; Paul Goldsmith, Independent Electoral Review final report released, Scoop, 16 January 2024, for the number of submissions. The report names Deborah Hart as the panel’s chair.
What it recommended on MMP
- Lower the threshold to 3.5 percent.
- End the one-electorate rule, provided the threshold was lowered.
- No extra seats for an overhang. As in 2012, a party would keep every electorate it won and other parties would receive fewer list seats. The panel said the changes should be considered as a package.
- Fix the balance of electorate and list seats at 60 to 40, letting Parliament grow with the population.
- Entrench the rules for allocating seats and the threshold, so that they could be changed only by 75 percent of MPs or by a referendum. Changing these rules by a bare majority, it said, risks political manipulation.
The panel explained its concern. More frequent overhangs would make the size of Parliament unpredictable and could affect forming a government, because every extra seat raises the number of votes a government needs. It also recorded the case against its own proposal: taking list seats from other parties gives a party with strong local support a windfall. That is our objection too. The rule favours parties whose support is concentrated in electorates, and it discriminates against minorities whose supporters are spread across the country. See who would gain and who would pay.
Source: the final report, linked above: recommendations R3, R7, R8, R9 and R10; paragraphs 2.67 to 2.70 on entrenchment; paragraphs 4.92 and 4.98 to 4.101 on the overhang.
2024 to 2026: the response
On the day of release the Justice Minister, Paul Goldsmith, ruled out four recommendations: votes at 16, votes for all prisoners, the fixed balance of electorate and list seats, and repeal of the offence of treating. The rest, he said, would get a formal response in due course. We have not found a decision on the threshold, the overhang or entrenchment, and the overhang rule was unchanged at the 2026 election.
Fixing the balance of seats was the panel’s answer to a slow drift. As the population grows, the number of electorates grows and the number of list seats shrinks, which makes overhangs larger and more frequent. With that answer ruled out, the drift continues.
Sources: RNZ, Government rejects four voting changes as review lands, 16 January 2024; Paul Goldsmith, Independent Electoral Review final report released, as above; the final report, paragraph 4.118, on the drift.
Two reviews, one answer, no change. Twice in eleven years independent reviewers advised removing the provision for overhang seats, and twice the law stayed as it was. In 2026 the overhang reached 11 seats on election-night figures. We take up the reviews’ call for entrenchment: the fix should be passed into law and protected. See why entrenchment matters.