Open letter · released 18 November 2026
The experts’ open letter: Keep the “P” in MMP
Forty-six electoral experts have asked every party in the new Parliament to fix MMP this term. This page sets out what their letter says, who signed it and where to read it.
The letter in short
- Who: 46 signatories. They include a former Prime Minister, two former heads of the Electoral Commission, the chairs of the 2012 and 2023 electoral reviews, and political scientists and lawyers from seven universities.
- To whom: the members of New Zealand’s new Parliament, of every party.
- What it says: the 2026 election showed a weakness in MMP’s rules, and the rules should be changed this term so that MMP stays proportional.
- What it asks for: an urgent select committee inquiry with MPs from all parties, reporting by mid-2027.
This is the signatories’ letter, not ours. SaveMMP did not write or sign it, and the signatories have not endorsed SaveMMP. The summary below is in our words. Read the original for theirs.
What the letter says
MMP is meant to be proportional
The letter starts from what New Zealanders chose. They voted for MMP three times, in 1992, 1993 and 2011. They chose a system in which each party’s share of the seats closely matches its share of the vote, and in which a vote counts the same wherever the voter lives.
Under MMP the party vote should decide how many MPs each party has. The electorate vote should decide only who represents each local community.
What 2026 exposed
The letter says the 2026 election showed a significant weakness in the detail of New Zealand’s MMP. The two votes stopped doing their separate jobs, partly by accident and partly by design. Nothing like it had been seen in thirty years of MMP.
It gives two examples from the preliminary results. The party that came second in the party vote would have six more MPs than the party that came first. Another party would have five times the MPs its party vote earned. The letter calls these outcomes not proportional, and says they give some voters more power than others.
The 1986 Royal Commission, which recommended MMP, thought such results very unlikely and thought that gaming the system would be hard and unpopular. The letter says that view belonged to the politics of the 1980s. Today the two large parties together win less than 60 percent of the vote, so a large party can end up with an overhang again at any election unless the rules change.
Our own case on this point: it decides who governs.
The risk of an arms race
The letter warns that an overhang was not hard to bring about in 2026, and that the informal checks against it will not hold. Parties and voters have seen that it works. Each side can be expected to answer the other with the same tactics.
It sees a real risk that elections turn into a contest over who can best steer their voters towards a disproportionate result. This has happened in other countries. One next step would be for parties to stand their sitting electorate MPs as independents.
Some voters already question the result, and found the campaign talk about splitting votes confusing. If this becomes a normal part of elections, the letter expects people to lose trust and to feel that the system is rigged.
Its conclusion: the incentives must change now, so that an honest vote for the party and candidate a person prefers is worth more than a tactical one.
Our own case on these points: it feeds itself, and it won’t stop, and left alone, it puts MMP at risk.
The four options the letter names
The letter asks all parties to commit to changing MMP’s settings this term. It gives four examples of how. It does not prefer one of them. It says each has strengths and weaknesses, that other options exist, and that they should be weighed openly with the public taking part.
The fourth option is the one SaveMMP has worked out in detail. See where we stand.
What the letter asks Parliament to do
- Hold an urgent select committee inquiry with MPs from every party in Parliament. The letter names two models: the MMP Review Committee of 2000–2001 and the Electoral Legislation Committee of 2010–2011.
- Keep it narrow. The inquiry should look at this problem only.
- Report by mid-2027, so that a Government Bill can change the Electoral Act 1993 well before the next general election.
- Hear the public. The inquiry should take public submissions and advice from officials and experts.
- Work from principle. The changes should rest on proportionality and fairness, and be acceptable to as many parties as possible.
- Fit New Zealand. The inquiry should study other countries, and also what suits New Zealand’s own constitution, including Te Tiriti o Waitangi / the Treaty of Waitangi.
- Start from earlier reviews, the 2012 MMP Review and the 2023 Independent Electoral Review, while noting that neither fully considered the problem seen in 2026.
The letter ends by urging all parties to work together, and soon.
Why we think Parliament needs to be asked: nobody else will fix it.
The 46 signatories
In the letter’s own alphabetical order, with the description the letter gives for each.
- Professor Maria Bargh, Victoria University of Wellington
- Thomas Beagle, Chairperson, New Zealand Council for Civil Liberties
- Emeritus Professor Jonathan Boston, Victoria University of Wellington
- Nick Clark, Senior Fellow, New Zealand Initiative
- Dr Eddie Clark, Victoria University of Wellington
- Dr Helena Cook, University of Canterbury
- Dr Sam Crawley, Victoria University of Wellington
- Professor Jennifer Curtin, University of Auckland
- Dr Will Dreyer
- Andrew Ecclestone, Adjunct Senior Research Fellow, Victoria University of Wellington
- Professor Chris Eichbaum, Victoria University of Wellington
- Dr Luke Fitzmaurice-Brown, Victoria University of Wellington
- Professor Jon Fraenkel, Victoria University of Wellington
- Professor Andrew Geddis, University of Otago
- Dr Grant Gillon, former MP and academic
- Associate Professor Lara Greaves, Victoria University of Wellington
- Julie Haggie, Chief Executive, Transparency International New Zealand
- Dr Paul Harris, Principal Research Officer of the 1986 Royal Commission on the Electoral System and Chief Executive, Electoral Commission, 1994–2003
- Deborah Hart, Chair of the 2023 Independent Electoral Review
- Dr Oliver Hartwich, Executive Director, New Zealand Initiative
- Professor Bronwyn Hayward (MNZM, FRSNZ), University of Canterbury
- Professor Janine Hayward, University of Otago
- Emeritus Professor Ella Henry (MNZM), Auckland University of Technology
- Dr Leon Iusitini, Auckland University of Technology
- Dr Tom Jamieson, Victoria University of Wellington
- Professor Dean Knight, Victoria University of Wellington
- Dr Lindsey Te Ata o Tū MacDonald, University of Canterbury
- Alice Mander, member of the 2023 Independent Electoral Review
- Emeritus Professor Elizabeth McLeay, Victoria University of Wellington
- Dr Sylvia Nissen, Lincoln University
- Professor Dominic O’Sullivan, Auckland University of Technology and Victoria University
- Rt Hon Sir Geoffrey Palmer, KC, former Prime Minister
- Robert Peden, former Chief Electoral Officer
- Max Rashbrooke, Research Director, IDEA
- Dr Claire Robinson, former Professor
- Associate Professor Matheson Russell, University of Auckland
- Professor Richard Shaw, Massey University
- Associate Professor Andrew Sporle, University of Auckland
- Dr Michael Swanson, University of Otago
- Professor Alex Tan, University of Canterbury
- Dr Claire Timperley, Victoria University of Wellington
- Professor Jack Vowles, Victoria University of Wellington
- Associate Professor Paerau Warbrick, Otago University
- Dr Sean Whittaker, University of Otago
- Hon Sir Hugh Williams, KC, Electoral Commission Chair 2009–19 and Chair of the 2012 MMP Review Panel
- Dr Victoria Woodman, University of Auckland
How the parties have responded
These are the responses we have found so far, as at 20 November 2026, in the order they were made. We report them without taking sides.
- Green Party. The Greens support the letter’s call for a cross-party select committee inquiry. They are open to whichever option best keeps Parliament proportional, and say any change must uphold Te Tiriti o Waitangi and protect the Māori electorates. Press release, 18 November 2026 · the party’s Facebook post
- ACT. The party’s leader, David Seymour, said that voters may use their two votes as they choose. Reported by interest.co.nz, 18 November 2026
- Te Pāti Māori. The co-leaders say Māori voters used both their votes lawfully. They oppose the options that would cut electorates or turn away electorate winners, call for an eighth Māori electorate, and want Māori to take part in any review as Tiriti partners. Press release, 19 November 2026
We have not yet found a statement on the letter from the other parties in Parliament. We will add each one as it is made.
The original letter
Open Letter: Keep the “P” in MMP (PDF, four pages), as published by Law News, the news service of The Law Association.
The letter itself carries no date. It was made public on 18 November 2026. Its figures come from the preliminary count; the official results are declared on 27 November 2026.
This page is a summary in SaveMMP’s words and may not catch every shade of the original. Where the two differ, the letter is what counts. The copyright in the letter belongs to its authors.
Where SaveMMP stands
We welcome the letter, and we support its call for an inquiry with every party at the table and the public heard.
The letter lists options and leaves the choice open. We have taken its fourth option and worked it through: every electorate keeps the MP it chose, Parliament keeps 120 votes, and each party votes with exactly what its party vote earned.
We tolerate an overhang. We stop it from distorting proportionality.