Save MMP!

Our proposal

Why this is fair. And great.

A rule about who votes in Parliament has to be fair to voters, to electorates, to parties and to the MPs themselves. This page says why we think ours is, and what can fairly be said against it.

In brief

  • An MP does three things, and we change one. A non-voting MP still speaks for the electorate and still takes part in the decisions. Only the vote in the House goes.
  • Every party vote weighs the same, and every electorate keeps its MP. No winner is turned away, and no party loses a vote its party vote earned.
  • There is nothing to gain from an overhang. It becomes a side effect of the electoral process, not a way to win the House.
  • The spirit of the overhang rule is kept. Voters can still return the local MP they chose, whatever the party vote says. Only the extra votes in the House, the part that organised vote-splitting exploits, go. More below.
  • Stable majorities. Each party’s votes in the House stay as the party vote set them until the voters vote again.
  • Fit for the future. The rule is not a repair for one election. It holds whatever the pattern of votes. A fix for the future.

We tolerate an overhang. We stop it from distorting proportionality. For the rule itself, see the fix in five points.

An MP does three things. We change one.

For the people of an electorate, an MP does three things:

  1. Speaks for them. The MP takes up local people’s cases and raises local matters with Ministers, with departments and in Parliament.
  2. Takes part in the decisions. The MP helps to shape laws in the party’s caucus and in select committees, before any vote is called. In caucus the MP has the same vote as every other MP of the party.
  3. Votes in the House.

Our fix leaves the first two largely as they are; the limits are listed below. It takes away only the third, and only from the MPs a party has beyond what its party vote earned.

To get a law made or changed, a non-voting MP works with the party’s voting MPs in caucus, who cast the party’s votes in the House. That is how every MP gets things done today: no MP changes a law alone.

Germany’s rule since 2023 takes away all three: the electorate’s winner is not seated at all. We believe that is extremely harsh, and not a suitable fix for New Zealand. Here each electorate has one local MP, in a Parliament of only 120. An electorate left without the MP it chose would lose its voice in all three ways.

Our fix uses the same test as the German rule: what a party holds must be covered by its party vote. The difference is what an MP beyond that share loses. In Germany it is the seat. Under our fix it is only the vote in the House.

How a vote in the House is decided

Almost every vote in the House is a party vote. A party’s MPs meet in caucus and decide how the party will vote. The party’s votes are then cast together. No MP decides alone, except on a conscience vote. In caucus, all of a party’s MPs are equal, voting and non-voting.

Proportional, no overhang Government: 61 of 120 votes Opposition A · 35 35 Party A: 35 MPs decide how 35 votes are cast B · 14 14 C · 12 12 D · 40 40 E · 16 16 F Party F: 3 MPs decide how 3 votes are cast ▲ The House: 120 votes ▼ Caucus: 120 MPs Proportional, no overhang Government: 61 of 120 votes Opposition A · 35 35 Party A: 35 MPs decide how 35 votes are cast B 14 C 12 D · 40 40 E 16 F Party F: 3 MPs decide how 3 votes are cast ▲ The House: 120 votes ▼ Caucus: 120 MPs
Each party’s MPs decide in caucus how the party votes. Every MP in caucus stands for one vote in the House. Parties A, B and C hold 61 of the 120 votes, so they can govern and pass laws.
Proportional, with an overhang and our fix Government: 61 of 120 votes Opposition A · 35 35 Party A: 42 MPs decide how 35 votes are cast B · 14 14 C · 12 12 D · 40 40 E · 16 16 F Party F: 7 MPs decide how 3 votes are cast ▲ The House: 120 votes ▼ Caucus: 131 MPs Non-voting MPs: in caucus, no vote in the House Proportional, with an overhang and our fix Government: 61 of 120 votes Opposition A · 35 35 Party A: 42 MPs decide how 35 votes are cast B 14 C 12 D · 40 40 E 16 F Party F: 7 MPs decide how 3 votes are cast ▲ The House: 120 votes ▼ Caucus: 131 MPs Non-voting MPs: in caucus, no vote in the House
Parties A and F have won more electorates than their party vote earned. The House is exactly as before: the same 120 votes, the same majority. In caucus, all 42 MPs of party A decide how its 35 votes are cast, and all 7 MPs of party F decide how its 3 votes are cast.

On 2026 election-night figures, all 42 National MPs would decide together how National’s 35 votes are cast, and all 5 Te Pāti Māori MPs would decide how its 1 vote is cast.

So the electorate’s MP still has a say where the decision is made. What changes is the count in the House: it matches the party vote. That is the P in MMP.

Three limits, to be plain about them. On a conscience vote there is no party position, so a non-voting MP has no say in the result. Each party sets its own caucus rules; our draft law lays down one thing, that in caucus all of a party’s MPs are equal, voting and non-voting, on every matter, including discipline. And a non-voting MP does not speak in debates. They speak in the chamber on arriving and on leaving, and are heard there at least once a year as of right, and more often when the House agrees.

Fair to voters

MMP makes one promise: the party vote decides how strong each party is in Parliament. Our fix keeps that promise at every election, close or not.

  • Every party vote weighs the same. Today, a party with an overhang holds more votes in Parliament than its party vote earned. The voters of every other party are outweighed. On 2026 election-night figures National holds 42 votes in Parliament on a party vote that earned 35, so each of its party votes carries 1.2 times the weight it earned. Te Pāti Māori holds 5 on a party vote that earned 1: five times. Under our fix, each party’s share of the 120 votes is its share of the party vote. Your party vote weighs the same as anyone else’s, wherever you live and whoever you vote for.
  • The majority you elect is the majority you get. In 2026, on election-night figures, extra seats turned one side’s exact half of the seats into a majority, and could decide who governs. The party vote did not choose that majority.
  • Pick the local candidate you prefer. You can choose your preferred candidate for electorate MP, whatever their party, without distorting the proportions in Parliament.
  • Your two votes stay free. You may still give your electorate vote and your party vote to different parties. Nobody is penalised for doing so.

Each vote does one thing

Nothing changes in how you vote or how the election is run. You still choose the local MP you prefer, and you still decide the shares of the parties in Parliament.

Your electorate voteYour party vote
TodayChooses the local MP. Where there is an overhang, it also adds a vote in Parliament beyond what the party vote earned.Decides the parties’ shares in Parliament, except where there is an overhang.
With our fixChooses the local MP.Decides the parties’ shares in Parliament. Always.

Today, splitting your two votes can count twice. With our fix you remain free to split them, but it gains nothing extra in Parliament. Every voter can see what each vote is for.

The rule works however people vote. It does not depend on anyone voting differently.

What about the voters whose MP has no vote?

They are represented in full, like everyone else.

  • Their party votes count in full, for the parties they gave them to.
  • They have the local MP they chose, with an office and staff in the electorate.

What they do not get is something extra: a vote in Parliament on top of what the party vote earned. An overhang gains only one advantage: local representation.

Fair to electorates

Every electorate keeps the MP it chose. That is the part of MMP most New Zealanders know best, and we leave it alone.

  • No winner is turned away. All 71 electorates keep the local MP they chose, overhang or not. In Germany in 2025, 23 electorate winners were left out of parliament.
  • Every electorate is treated alike. Each one keeps its office and its staff, whether or not its MP has a vote.
  • The electorate can still be heard. Its MP can raise local matters in a select committee, in writing to the House, and in the party.

Nothing to gain, nothing lost

Today an overhang rewards those who create it. Where enough voters split their two votes, their side ends up with more votes in Parliament than its party vote earned.

  • The reward is gone. However the two votes are used, each side gets the votes in Parliament its party vote earned. There is nothing extra to win by creating an overhang, for a voter or for a party.
  • Local representation stays. Nothing is taken from any electorate. Only the extra votes in the House go.
  • An overhang becomes a side effect of the electoral process, not a way to win the House. Any overhang that still arises is a by-product of how people chose their local MPs. That is how MMP was meant to work: the Royal Commission of 1986 treated an overhang as a remote side effect.

We make no forecast of how often an overhang will arise. Large or small, the House has 120 votes, shared out as the party vote decided.

Fair to parties

  • One rule for all. It applies in the same way to large and small parties, and to government and opposition. On 2026 election-night figures, both sides of Parliament hold extra seats. This is a fault in the rules, not a charge against any party.
  • Known before the election. Which of a party’s MPs hold its votes follows the order of its list, lodged before the election. Nobody chooses afterwards.
  • No party pays for another’s overhang. Other ways of keeping Parliament at 120 take the extra seats out of other parties’ list seats. Ours takes nothing from any party that its party vote earned.
  • No extra funding or staff. Funding and staff for a party’s work in Parliament follow its votes, not the number of its MPs.

Fair to the MPs concerned

A non-voting MP is a member of Parliament for every purpose except voting in the House.

  • They are MPs. They take the oath, are paid as MPs, and have a guaranteed place on a select committee.
  • They can gain a vote. When a voting MP of the same party leaves Parliament, for example by retiring, the vote passes to the party’s next non-voting MP, in list order.
  • It is not permanent. It is decided afresh at every election, and the voters can change it with their party votes.
  • Their rights are protected. We want these rights written into the Electoral Act, so that a majority of the day cannot take them away.

How non-voting MPs would work

Stable majorities, for the whole three years

What the voters decided at the election holds until the next one.

Today every electorate seat carries a vote. A change of electorate MP in the middle of a term can change the numbers in Parliament, and a narrow majority can be lost in one local contest.

It has happened here. In March 2015 the National MP for Northland resigned, and Winston Peters of New Zealand First won the by-election. National went from 60 seats to 59 in a Parliament of 121, and New Zealand First from 11 to 12. Until then National could pass a law with the one vote of ACT. Afterwards it could not, and it no longer had a majority for its planned changes to the Resource Management Act. One local contest, six months after the general election, changed what the Government could pass. Under our fix Northland would have had the MP it chose, and each party’s votes in Parliament would have stayed as the party vote set them in 2014.

Sources: Electoral Commission, Northland by-election official results, April 2015; RNZ News, 29 and 30 March 2015.

With our fix the votes belong to the parties, as the party vote set them at the general election.

  • The balance holds. Each party keeps exactly the votes its party vote earned until the voters vote again. No by-election can change that.
  • A by-election changes the local MP, and nothing else. No party gains votes in Parliament by forcing or timing one.
  • A change of party changes nothing either. An MP who leaves their party cannot take a vote away from the party the voters gave it to. The same holds for an MP expelled by their party, if two-thirds of all its MPs agree, voting and non-voting alike. An electorate MP keeps the seat. A list MP who leaves the party or is expelled leaves Parliament, and the next person on the party’s list comes in.
  • A majority is always 61 of 120 votes, however many MPs there are.

More than fair: why we think it is a good rule

  • It keeps what people value in MMP. A local MP for every electorate, and a Parliament that matches the party vote. Other fixes give up one to keep the other.
  • It keeps the spirit of the overhang rule. The rule protects local choice: voters can return an independent, an MP who has left their party or a new party’s candidate, whatever the party vote says. We keep that protection and take away only what organised vote-splitting exploits, the extra votes in the House. Gerry Brownlee, the outgoing Speaker, called organised splitting “a real perversion of what MMP was supposed to be about”. More on the spirit of the rule.
  • Nothing changes on the ballot paper. Two ticks, as now. Voters have nothing new to learn.
  • No seats are added to balance. The votes in the House never grow, and it costs no more than today’s rules.
  • It works for an overhang of any size. One extra seat or twenty, the votes in Parliament stay at 120 and follow the party vote.
  • It comes very close to the party vote. On the results of two German state elections, our rule matched the party vote more closely than the rules those states use, without one added seat. See the comparison.

What can fairly be said against it

No answer to the overhang is free of cost. These are the strongest objections we know, and what we say to each.

It creates two kinds of MP

It does, and we say so plainly. But of the three things an MP does, only one is affected, and the MP still takes part where the party’s votes are decided. We weigh what remains against the alternatives: a Parliament whose majority the party vote did not choose, a Parliament that keeps growing, or electorates whose chosen MP is turned away. We think an MP who serves without a vote for a time is the smallest of these costs.

A strong local winner may have no vote

Under our draft the party’s list decides, so an MP who won an electorate by a wide margin could be non-voting while a narrower winner votes. The other way would be to rank a party’s winners by their share of the local vote. We chose the list: it is lodged before the election, voters can see it, and a party must put every one of its electorate candidates on it.

It does not fall evenly

The rule is the same for every party, but it bites only where there is an overhang. On 2026 election-night figures that is National, with 7 non-voting MPs out of 42, and Te Pāti Māori, with 4 out of 5. For a small party that wins most of its support in electorates, most of its MPs would be non-voting.

We do not wave this away. Each of those parties would hold exactly the votes its party vote earned, as every other party does. The rule changes what the Māori electorates deliver in votes in the House. That change should be made with Māori agreement.

A non-voting MP has a limited voice in debates

Under our draft a non-voting MP does not sit in the debating chamber. They have a permanent place in the gallery, and speak in the chamber on arriving and on leaving. They are heard there at least once a year as of right, and more often when the House agrees. Whether that is enough is still open. See what is still open.

A simple test

Ask whether you would accept the rule without knowing which party it will fall on next time.

Under today’s rules the answer depends on who gains. Under our fix it does not: whoever wins, each party holds the votes its party vote earned, and every electorate has its MP.

Tell us what you think. Send us a message.

The fix in five points · Non-voting MPs · Why the overhang must be fixed · A fix for the future · Frequently Asked Questions · Get involved