Save MMP!

Our proposal in law

The changes in law

We tolerate an overhang. We stop it from distorting proportionality. Here is the exact wording we propose, so that anyone can check it.

Download the complete draft as PDF

In brief

  • One bill changes four Acts. The draft Electoral (Proportional Voting Strength) Amendment Bill changes the Electoral Act 1993. It also makes the changes that follow from it in the Constitution Act 1986 and the Parliament Act 2025, and in one section of the Broadcasting Act 1989.
  • Parliament changes its own rules. Much of the detail belongs in the Standing Orders. The House adopts those changes itself. They are drafted here as well.
  • The “waka-jumping” law is repealed in full. Sections 55AAB to 55E of the Electoral Act 1993 go. An electorate MP who leaves their party keeps the seat, and the vote stays with the party, so the balance of Parliament cannot change. A list MP who leaves the party leaves Parliament, as now. See clause 8.
  • This is a first draft. It shows that the proposal can be written into law, and how. It still has 8 open questions, and points marked for a lawyer to check.

First draft for legal review, 16 November 2026. This is not a Government bill. It has not been drafted or checked by the Parliamentary Counsel Office, and lawyers have not yet reviewed it. It contains open questions and points marked for a lawyer to check. It is written in the form of a bill to show the changes in full; we ask that it be taken up as a Government bill, drafted by the Parliamentary Counsel Office.

Electoral Act 1993

This is the heart of the fix. The draft separates the seat from the vote: every electorate winner sits, and each party has exactly the votes its party vote earned.

Read on the website · Electoral Act 1993 changes (PDF)

Constitution Act 1986

A Minister must be an MP with a vote, and so must a Parliamentary Under-Secretary and the Speaker.

Read on the website · Constitution Act 1986 changes (PDF)

Parliament Act 2025

Money for a party’s work in Parliament follows its votes. Every electorate keeps the funding for its office, and an MP’s pay does not depend on having a vote. One section of the Broadcasting Act 1989 changes in the same way.

Read on the website · Parliament Act 2025 changes (PDF)

Standing Orders

The Standing Orders are Parliament’s own rules. These changes set out how the House counts votes and how non-voting MPs take part.

Read on the website · Standing Orders changes (PDF)

The path into law

A draft is not a law. For the fix to apply at the next election, due in 2029, Parliament has to pass it, and we want it entrenched as well.

  • Seven steps, about 22 months. From the day an inquiry starts to the day the Governor-General signs the law, by our estimate.
  • The work must start in early 2027. The Electoral Commission then has about a year to prepare.
  • Entrenchment travels in the same bill. It needs three-quarters of all MPs, public submissions and no urgency.

The path into law: every step, who takes it, and the time each takes →

How to read the draft

  • New wording stands on a tinted background with a purple line. The text around it says where it goes in the law.
  • Open The point is not decided. “Open question 20” refers to the list of open questions.
  • To check A point a lawyer needs to confirm, such as a section number.
  • The draft uses the words of the law: “member” for an MP, “electoral district” for an electorate, “constituency candidate” for an electorate candidate.

The draft is written against these versions of the law, read on 16 November 2026: the Electoral Act 1993 as at 1 January 2026; the Constitution Act 1986 as at 4 September 2026; the Parliament Act 2025 as at 23 September 2026; and the Standing Orders of the House of Representatives 2026. Law changes made in 2026 after those dates have not been checked.

The Standing Order numbers and headings used in the draft were checked on 19 November 2026 against the 2026 edition published on Parliament’s website. The printed volume prevails over the web text, so a final check against the print remains.

What the Bill does

This is the general policy statement from the draft Bill’s explanatory note.

This Bill gives effect to a proposal for “A Proportional 120-Member Parliament with Electorate Representation”.

Under the Electoral Act 1993, each party’s share of the 120 seats is set by its party vote under section 191 (the Sainte-Laguë method). If a party wins more electorates than that share, it keeps the extra electorate seats (section 192(5)), and the House grows beyond 120 members. These extra seats (the “overhang”) carry full votes. As a result, the voting strength of parties in the House no longer matches the party vote. Section 191(8) also deducts independent members, and members of unlisted parties who win electorates, from the 120 seats before the party-vote allocation.

The Bill keeps every electorate winner in the House and keeps the voting strength of the House exactly proportional. It rests on one principle. Representation can be gained through the electorate vote: an electorate gives its member a seat. The right to vote in the House derives from the party vote alone: the party vote gives a party its votes. The Bill therefore separates the seat from the vote:

  • Every electorate winner takes a seat and is a member of Parliament for all purposes.
  • Each party has as many voting places as its entitlement under section 191, and no more. The House therefore always has 120 votes, however many members it has. The one exception is a voting place that cannot be filled because a party’s list is exhausted: it stays empty until the next general election, as an unfilled list seat does now.
  • Members elected beyond a party’s entitlement, and members elected without a party vote, sit as non-voting members.

The main features are as follows.

Voting places in list order. A party’s voting places are held by its members in the order of the party list lodged before the election. Where a party wins more electorates than its entitlement, the electorate winners who stand highest on its list hold the voting places. A candidate must be on the party list to hold a voting place, and a party must put every one of its electorate candidates on its list. Each member’s status is fixed when the result is declared. It changes only when a voting place falls vacant. The place then passes to the party’s next member in list order who sits without a vote, or, if there is none, it is filled from the list under section 137. A party cannot reassign voting places after the election.

An electorate seat belongs to the member, a list seat to the party vote that filled it, and the vote always to the party. An electorate member who leaves their party keeps their seat but gives up their vote. The voting place stays with the party. For this reason the Bill repeals sections 55A to 55E of the Electoral Act 1993 (the “waka-jumping” or party-hopping provisions). Those sections protect proportionality by vacating the seat of a member who leaves their party. Under this Bill a member who leaves their party gives up the vote, and the vote stays with the party, so proportionality is protected without unseating an electorate member. A member expelled by their party is treated in the same way, but only if at least two-thirds of all the party’s members of Parliament, voting and non-voting alike, agree to the notice. A list member who leaves their party, or is expelled from it, leaves Parliament: the seat becomes vacant and is filled from the party’s list. For list members the effect of the party-hopping provisions is therefore kept.

Voting places are fixed for the term. By-elections and changes of party do not change any party’s number of voting places during the term. A party’s candidate who wins a by-election without having been on its list joins the list at the foot.

Independents as a “party of one”. An electorate candidate who does not stand for a registered party may choose between two options:

  • Nationwide: register as a party of one and appear on every party-vote ballot. The party of one gains voting strength only if its party vote earns a place under section 191. Under Sainte-Laguë with 120 places this takes about 0.42% of the party vote, which is half of the 0.83% quota. The quota is not changed. The 5% threshold is waived for a party of one only through the existing one-electorate rule, that is, only if the candidate wins the electorate.
  • Local only: stand on nomination alone, appear only on the electorate ballot, and receive no party vote. If elected, the candidate sits as a non-voting member.

Any party, including a party of one, may decline the party vote before nominations close. The opt-out is shown on the ballot paper and is fixed for the term. Section 191(8) is repealed, so all 120 voting places are allocated by party vote.

Rights of non-voting members. Non-voting members are members of Parliament for all purposes except voting in the House. This includes the oath, salary, privileges, an electorate office and constituency services. They have the following rights as of right:

  • to take part and vote in the decisions of their party’s members of Parliament (the caucus) on the same terms as its voting members, including on discipline;
  • to lodge written questions to Ministers, as any member may, and to propose a member’s bill jointly with a voting member of their party;
  • to present written statements and reports on electorate matters directly to the House, which are published and referred to a select committee, which must report on them;
  • a guaranteed place, without a vote, on a select committee of the member’s choosing, with the right to speak and move motions;
  • to make a maiden statement and a valedictory statement in the House; and
  • to be heard orally by the House on a specified matter at least once in each calendar year, with questions from voting members.

The House may order that a non-voting member be heard on further occasions. Non-voting members are members, not strangers. They do not sit in the debating chamber. They enter it to be sworn in, to make their maiden and valedictory statements, and to be heard. They have a permanent place in a gallery of the House, at all times, to observe its proceedings. In the House’s proceedings and ceremonies they rank after voting members and above Officers of Parliament.

Offices that require a vote. Ministers, the Speaker, the Deputy Speaker, Assistant Speakers, the Leader of the Opposition, party leaders recognised in the House, whips, select committee chairpersons and deputy chairpersons, and Parliamentary Under-Secretaries must be voting members.

Counting. Majorities and other counts in the House are counted in the votes of voting members.

Resources follow entitlement. Funding and staff for parties’ parliamentary operations follow each party’s voting places, not its headcount. Electorate office funding continues for every electorate member. Salaries remain a matter for the Remuneration Authority.

Entrenchment. Part 2A adds the structure of MMP, with the new rules as part of it, to the reserved provisions in section 268: the House’s members, the two votes, a party’s right to be registered, party lists, the allocation of seats by party vote (including the existence of a threshold, but not its level), voting strength equal to entitlement and the allocation of voting places, every electorate winner’s seat, the rights of non-voting members, voting and counting in the House, the rule that vacancies do not change voting strength, and the existence of the Māori electorates. How votes are collected and counted stays with ordinary law. Part 2A is voted on separately: if it does not reach 75% of all members, it falls away and the rest of the Bill is unaffected. The Bill states that it does not make these rights enforceable in a court beyond what parliamentary privilege allows.

Out of scope. The Bill does not deal with campaign finance, with law changes made in 2026, with voter suppression, or with the level of the party-vote threshold. The 5% threshold in section 191(4)(a) is left as it is. Changing the threshold is an option for separate consideration.

Standing Orders. Many of the mechanics belong in the Standing Orders of the House. A separate part of this draft sets out amendments to the Standing Orders 2026. The Bill requires the Standing Orders to provide for the statutory rights.

Where each rule is in the draft

cl = clause of the Bill. s = section of the Electoral Act 1993, unless another Act is named. SO = Standing Order. B1 to B24 = the numbered changes to the Standing Orders (with B1A and B7A). Sch = Schedule.

What the rule doesIn the BillIn the Standing Orders
Definitionscl 5 (s 3(1)); cl 6 (s 27(2))B1 (SO 3)
The principle: representation through the electorate vote; the right to vote from the party vote alonecl 3(b); cl 10 (s 59A(b), s 59C(1A))—
Every electorate winner takes a seatcl 10 (s 59B)—
Voting strength = entitlement; House has 120 votescl 10 (s 59C); cl 16 (s 192(6)); cl 18 (s 193B)B11 (SO 140(2))
Voting places filled in party-list ordercl 10 (s 59D); cl 18 (s 193B(2))—
Over-entitled party: highest-listed electorate winners votecl 18 (s 193B(3))—
Must be on party list to hold a voting placecl 10 (s 59D(2)); cl 16 (s 192(2)); cl 18 (s 193B(4)(b))—
Every electorate candidate of a party must be on its listcl 12 (s 127D)—
Status fixed at declarationcl 10 (s 59D(3)–(4)); cl 17 (s 193(5)); cl 18 (s 193B(6)–(7))B5 (SO 36(1)(c))
Vacant voting place: next non-voting member in list order, else s 137cl 10 (s 59E); cl 20 (s 134(4)); cl 21 (s 137(1A)–(1B))—
No reassignment by partycl 10 (s 59D(5))—
One-electorate rule kept; threshold unchangedcl 15 (s 191(4) unchanged; s 191(4B))—
Electorate seat belongs to member, vote to party: electorate member who leaves keeps the seat and loses the votecl 10 (s 59F(2), (4))B4 (SO 35(1A))
Non-voting member who leaves stays without a votecl 10 (s 59F(5))—
Repeal of ss 55A–55Ecl 7 (s 55(1)(fa)); cl 8; cl 9 (s 133)—
Expulsion treated as leaving, on a notice agreed by two-thirds of all the party’s members, voting and non-votingcl 10 (s 59F(3), (3A))—
List member who leaves the party, or is expelled, leaves Parliament; the seat is filled from the listcl 7 (s 55(1)(fb)); cl 10 (s 59F(7))—
Voting places fixed for the termcl 10 (s 59C(4), s 59G(1))—
By-election winner from full party sits without a vote; vacated place stays with partycl 10 (s 59G(2)–(4)); cl 19 (s 129(5))—
By-election winner not on the party’s list joins the foot of the list; no other name is added during the termcl 10 (s 59G(2A)–(2B))—
Independent, or candidate of a party with no voting places, who wins a by-election sits without a votecl 10 (s 59G(5))—
Party of one: registration, with 500 members as for any partycl 11 (s 63B)—
Nationwide option: on every party-vote ballotcl 12 (s 127B); cl 14 (s 150(9A)); Sch 2—
Voting strength only if party vote earns a place; quota unchanged; 5% waived only via electorate wincl 12 (s 127B(5)); cl 15 (s 191(4B))—
Local-only option: electorate ballot only, sits without a votecl 13 (s 143(1A)–(1B)); cl 18 (s 193B(4)(c))—
Declared opt-out from party vote, on ballot, fixed for termcl 12 (s 127C); cl 14 (s 150(6)(da)); Sch 2—
Repeal of s 191(8)cl 15 (s 191(7)–(8))—
Members for all purposes except votingcl 10 (s 59H); cl 30 (Parliament Act s 71(2A))B7 (SO 45A(1))
Written statements and reports, published and referred; no limit on their number; the committee must reportcl 10 (s 59I, including (6)–(7))B22 (new SO 381A, including (6))
Guaranteed select committee place of the member’s choosing, speak and move motions, no vote; places additional and capped per committeecl 10 (s 59J, including (3) and (4A))B15 (SO 186, new SO 186A including (2) and (2A), SO 187(4), SO 188(5)); B17 (SO 213(2))
Oral address as of right: maiden and valedictory statements, and a hearing at least once a yearcl 10 (s 59K(1)–(2))B20 (SO 368); B21 (new SO 368A(1))
Hearings: yearly as of right, further ones by order of the House; questions from voting members; minimum times; the Speaker decides for independentscl 10 (s 59K(2)–(6))B21 (new SO 368A, including (3A), (5) and (6A))
Written questions as any member; a member’s bill jointly with a voting member, counting as that member’s entry—B23 (SO 392); B19 (new SO 286A)
A non-voting member who becomes a voting member is recognised by the Housecl 10 (s 59E(6))B7A (new SO 45B)
Standing: not strangers; not seated in the Chamber; a permanent place in a gallery; rank after voting members and above Officers of Parliamentcl 10 (s 59L)B7 (new SO 45A); B8 (SO 38(1A))
MMP as a whole and the core rules entrenched in s 268, in a separate Part; a party’s right to be registered included; the existence of a threshold, not its levelcl 25A (s 268(1)(g)–(p), including (na))B18 (SO 270)
Not enforceable in court beyond privilege Open: legal advicecl 10 (s 59Q)—
A non-voting member takes part and votes in the party’s caucus on equal terms; no other statutory caucus rule; whips cast votes for voting strengthcl 10 (s 59H(2A), s 59F(3A), s 59M(3), s 59P)B12 (SO 143, SO 144(3A))
Conscience (personal) votes: voting members onlycl 10 (s 59M(1)–(2))B13 (SO 148, 152, 154)
No dissent (separate vote) for non-voting membercl 10 (s 59M(2)(b))B12 (SO 145(4), (6))
Ministers must be voting memberscl 10 (s 59N(1)(a)); cl 26 (Constitution Act s 6)—
Speaker must be a voting member; the Speaker’s vote is cast with the party, as nowcl 10 (s 59N(2)); cl 28 (Constitution Act s 12)B2 (SO 17, 20); B14 (SO 156)
Deputy Speaker must be a voting membercl 10 (s 59N(1)(b))B3 (SO 27, new SO 31A)
Assistant Speakers must be voting memberscl 10 (s 59N(1)(c))B3 (SO 29, new SO 31A)
Leader of the House (Minister by convention; mentioned in SO 284, not created by SOs)cl 10 (s 59N(1)(a)); cl 26— (covered as a Minister)
Shadow Leader of the House (colloquial title; not in SOs): the member a party names to speak on the business of the House must be a voting member—B5 (SO 36(1B))
Leader of the Opposition must be a voting membercl 10 (s 59N(1)(d))B6 (SO 37)
Party leaders recognised in the House must be voting memberscl 10 (s 59N(1)(e))B5 (SO 36(1A))
Whips must be voting memberscl 10 (s 59N(1)(f))B5 (SO 36(1A))
Select committee chairpersons and deputy chairpersons must be voting memberscl 10 (s 59N(1)(g))B16 (SO 204(1A)); B15 (SO 186A(6))
Parliamentary Under-Secretaries must be voting memberscl 10 (s 59N(1)(h)); cl 27 (Constitution Act s 8)—
Party funding and staff by voting placescl 29 (Parliament Act s 85(1A))—
Party size, where funding or a service depends on it, means voting placescl 29 (Parliament Act s 85(1AB))—
Parliamentary Service Commission: a party with 30 or more voting placescl 31 (Parliament Act s 155(1)(c))—
Election broadcasting money has regard to a party’s voting memberscl 32 (Broadcasting Act 1989 s 78(2)(c))—
Electorate office funding for every electoratecl 29 (Parliament Act s 85(1B)); cl 10 (s 59H(2)(c))—
Salaries unchanged (Remuneration Authority)cl 30 (Parliament Act s 71(2A))—
Majorities and counts in votes of voting memberscl 10 (s 59M(4))B9 (SO 78); B11 (SO 140, 141); B13 (SO 154); B18 (SO 270(3))
“75% of all the members” = 90 of 120cl 10 (s 59M(5)); cl 25A (s 268(2A)); cl 23 (ss 131, 136)B18 (SO 270(3A))
Counted in voting members or voting places: six for a new party; 61 for a member’s bill without the ballot; the share of oral questions; the number present to suspend Standing Orders—B4 (SO 35(2)(b)(ii)); B19 (SO 288(3)–(4)); B23 (SO 391(2)); B1A (SO 4(2))
Commencement and transitioncl 2; cl 24; Sch 1(adoption under SO 6)

Open questions

These are the points the draft leaves open, or marks for a lawyer to check. The numbers are the ones the draft refers to. In brackets: the clause, section or Standing Order concerned.

  1. Component parties (ss 192(2)(b), 193B(5))
  2. Enforceability and exclusive cognisance (s 59Q)
  3. Funding determination (Parliament Act s 85(1A)–(1C))
  4. Timing of the repeal of ss 55A–55E
  5. New Zealand Bill of Rights Act 1990
  6. Other enactments
  7. Standing Orders 2026 edition and numbering
  8. The term “non-voting member” and the Standing Orders (s 3(1); SO 187; SO 213(2))

Have you found a mistake, or do you know this area of law? Send us a message.

The fix in five points · Non-voting MPs: how it would work