Our proposal
Entrenchment
A rule that a bare majority can bring in, a bare majority can also take away. We want the fix passed, and then entrenched: protected in law, so that a bare majority cannot undo it.
In brief
- MMP itself is not protected today. A bare majority of MPs could change how seats are shared out.
- We want MMP and the fix protected together. After that, a change would need three-quarters of all MPs, or a majority of voters in a referendum.
- How people vote stays flexible. How votes are collected and counted stays with ordinary law. The method of voting stays protected, as now.
- The fix does not depend on it. If the protection cannot be won now, the fix should still pass.
What entrenchment is
Most laws can be changed by a bare majority of MPs: half, plus one. A few rules are too important for that. They are entrenched, which means they can only be changed in one of two ways:
- by 75 percent of all MPs, or
- by a majority of voters in a referendum.
New Zealand has done this since 1956. Today it rests on one provision, section 268 of the Electoral Act 1993. It protects six rules:
- the three-year term of Parliament
- the Representation Commission, which draws electorate boundaries
- the way the country is divided into general electorates
- the allowance by which an electorate’s population may vary
- the voting age of 18
- the method of voting.
What is not protected today
MMP is not on that list. Nor are the rules that share out the seats by the party vote, the threshold, the overhang rules or the Māori electorates. A bare majority of MPs could change any of them.
That matters for two reasons.
The rules of the game should not belong to the winners. The rules decide who holds a majority. If a bare majority can rewrite them, the side that holds power can change the rules to keep it. This is true whichever parties govern.
A fix that can be undone is not finished. If our rule became law by a bare majority, the next majority could remove it the same way, perhaps at the moment an overhang would help it most.
We are not the first to say so. The Independent Electoral Review of 2023 recommended that the way seats are shared out, and the party vote threshold, be entrenched.
What we want protected
We want MMP protected as a whole, with the fix as part of it:
- A House of 120 votes.
- Two votes for every voter: an electorate vote and a party vote.
- Seats shared out by the party vote. That includes the rule that there is a threshold, but not its level: the percentage could still be lowered by an ordinary law.
- A party’s right to register and stand. A party with 500 paid-up members may register, put up a list and ask for party votes. A bare majority could not raise that bar to shut small parties out. The same goes for an independent who registers as a party of one.
- The fix: each party’s votes in the House equal what its party vote earned; votes and majorities in the House are counted in voting MPs; every electorate winner takes a seat; and the rights of non-voting MPs.
- The Māori electorates. Their existence would be protected. Their future stays for Māori to decide.
What stays with ordinary law
Protection should cover what a vote is worth, not the practical side of voting. How people enrol, how votes are collected and counted, how special votes are cast and how campaigns are run would stay with ordinary law, so that they can keep up with the times.
One rule on the practical side is already protected and we leave it as it is: the method of voting.
What it takes
Adding a rule to the protected list is harder than passing an ordinary law. Parliament’s own rules, the Standing Orders, require three things:
- Three-quarters of all MPs. A proposal that sets a 75 percent lock must itself be carried by 75 percent of all MPs. In the present Parliament that is 99 of the 131 MPs, on election-night figures. Once the fix is in force, 75 percent means 90 of the 120 votes, for any later change.
- Public submissions. A select committee must first hear from the public and report.
- No urgency. It cannot be rushed through.
A referendum alone cannot add the protection. The three-quarters vote in Parliament is needed either way. So protection needs broad agreement across parties, which is how it should be for the rules of the game.
See where these conditions fall on the path into law →
How strong is the protection? Section 268 does not protect itself. In strict law, a bare majority could repeal section 268 and then change the rules it guards. No Parliament has done so since 1956. The protection rests on the law and on that long-kept understanding together. Our draft leaves that as it is: it adds to the protected list and does not try to make section 268 protect itself.
If the protection cannot be won now
The fix does not depend on entrenchment. The rules that share out the seats are ordinary law today, so an ordinary majority can pass the fix.
For that reason the protecting clauses go into a separate Part of the same bill, voted on separately. If they fall short of three-quarters, the fix can still pass, and the protection can be added later.
An ordinary majority is the least that is needed. It is not our goal. Our goal is the fix, passed and protected.
In the draft law
The protecting clause is clause 25A of our draft changes to the Electoral Act, in a Part of its own that is voted on separately. It adds MMP as a whole, with the fix, to section 268.
The draft now lists what this page sets out. Some section numbers and points of detail are marked for a lawyer to check.
The fix in five points · Why this is fair · A fix for the future · The draft law · Get involved