Save MMP!

Questions and answers

Frequently Asked Questions

Short answers to the questions we expect, including the hard ones.

Why does Parliament have 131 MPs after the 2026 election?

Because of 11 overhang seats. On election-night figures, National’s party vote earned it 35 seats, but it won 42 electorates and kept all 42. Te Pāti Māori’s party vote earned it 1 seat, but it won 5 electorates and kept all 5. The official results are declared on 27 November 2026.

Does my party vote count the same as everyone else’s?

Not today. An overhang makes some votes worth more than others. On 2026 election-night figures National holds 42 votes in Parliament on a party vote that earned 35, so each of its party votes carries 1.2 times the weight it earned. Te Pāti Māori holds 5 on a party vote that earned 1: five times. Every other voter’s party vote is outweighed.

Under our fix every party vote counts the same: each party holds exactly the votes in Parliament that its party vote earned, wherever its voters live and whoever they voted for. One thing does not change. A party vote for a party that stays below the threshold and wins no electorate still earns no seats. That is a separate question.

Doesn’t MMP give a good candidate who loses an electorate a second chance on the list?

Yes, and that is one of the things MMP was built to do. A candidate can stand in an electorate and on the party list at once. But a party with an overhang gets no list seats at all, because its electorates already exceed what its party vote earned. For that party the list is no longer a safety net: a candidate who loses the electorate is out of Parliament. On 2026 election-night figures that is true of two parties, one on each side of the House.

Our fix takes away the reason to bring an overhang about, so parties would again seek the party vote and their lists would work again. More on what Parliament loses.

Is this the same as abolishing overhang seats?

No. Abolishing overhang seats keeps Parliament at 120 by taking seats from other parties, so the overhang party still has more than its party vote earned. It favours parties whose support is concentrated in electorates, and it is paid for by parties whose supporters are spread across the country and can win seats only through the party vote. That discriminates against spread minorities, whichever party gains. Under our fix every electorate MP keeps their seat, and each party’s votes in the House match its party vote exactly.

Is this the experts’ fourth option, or “weighted voting”?

Yes. It is the fourth option in the experts’ open letter of 18 November 2026: a party’s voting strength in Parliament is based on its party vote, not its total number of MPs. Others call it weighted voting, voting by party-vote entitlement, or “only party votes count in Parliament”. Pete Hodgson and Professor Jack Vowles have argued for a rule like it (what people say). SaveMMP has worked it through in detail: which MPs hold the votes, what non-voting MPs can do, by-elections, MPs who change party, and a draft law. The letter’s four options.

Is this Germany’s 2023 rule?

No. Since 2023 Germany has turned away the electorate winners its party vote does not cover, so some electorates have no MP at all. Under our fix every electorate winner takes their seat. Only the votes in the House follow the party vote. Germany’s three fixes.

Do you end coat-tailing?

No, and here is why. Coat-tailing means a party with less than 5 percent of the party vote wins one electorate and brings list MPs in with it. Two reviews proposed to end it by setting that party’s votes aside and giving its electorate winner a seat and a vote all the same. That is a vote in Parliament the party vote did not earn, which is the very thing our fix removes.

Under our fix every vote in Parliament comes from the party vote. A party that wins an electorate has its party votes counted, and it holds exactly the votes those earned: no more because of the electorate, and no fewer. Nobody comes in behind an electorate winner unless party votes put them there.

We do not claim this settles every objection. A party with an electorate still comes in below 5 percent when a party without one does not. That is a question about the threshold, and it can be decided separately without touching our fix. See coat-tailing in the dictionary.

Where does an MP’s vote in the House come from?

Representation can be gained through the electorate vote: it chooses the local MP and gives that MP a seat. Voting rights in the House are derived from the party vote alone: it decides how many votes each party has. So an electorate MP holds a vote only where the party vote has earned their party a vote for them to hold. Our draft law says this outright.

Which MPs lose their vote if a party wins too many electorates?

The party’s votes are held in the order of its list, lodged before the election. The electorate winners who stand highest on the list hold the votes; the rest keep their seats without a vote. Nobody chooses after the election, so it is not arbitrary. A party must put every one of its electorate candidates on its list, so no winner is left out for being unlisted.

Does an electorate MP lose their vote just for being low on the list?

No. An electorate MP votes unless their party has won more electorates than its party vote earned. Only then does the list order decide which of that party’s MPs hold its votes. Three smaller cases also sit without a vote: an independent who stands in the electorate only, a winner for a party that declines the party vote, and an electorate MP who leaves their party.

Could a non-voting MP be a Minister?

No. A Minister must be an MP with a vote. So must a Parliamentary Under-Secretary, the Speaker, and the chairperson or deputy chairperson of a select committee. Parties can place the people they want in these roles high on their list.

Can a non-voting MP gain a vote during the term?

Yes. When a voting MP of the same party leaves Parliament, for example by retiring, the vote stays with the party and passes to its next non-voting MP, in list order. Each party’s number of votes stays the same throughout the term. More on non-voting MPs.

Does a non-voting MP have a say in their party?

Yes, the same say as every other MP of the party. In caucus, all of a party’s MPs are equal, voting and non-voting. A non-voting MP takes part and votes there on every matter, including discipline, and caucus is where a party decides how its votes in the House are cast. Our draft law makes this a right. A party can expel one of its MPs only if two-thirds of all its MPs agree, voting and non-voting alike.

Can a non-voting MP question Ministers or propose a law?

Yes. A non-voting MP can put written questions to Ministers, like any other MP, and can propose a member’s bill jointly with a voting MP of the same party. The bill counts as that MP’s one entry in the ballot, so a party with extra MPs gets no extra entries, and the voting MP takes it through the House. More on non-voting MPs

Does a non-voting MP sit in the debating chamber?

No. A non-voting MP works in the party’s caucus, on a select committee and in the electorate. They have a permanent place in the gallery and may watch every sitting. They come into the chamber to be sworn in, to make a first speech on arriving and a farewell speech on leaving, and to be heard on a particular matter, at least once a year as of right and more often when the House agrees. Voting MPs may then put questions to them. On a select committee, which they choose for themselves, they speak, question witnesses and move motions like any other member.

Does a non-voting MP have any rights a voting MP does not have?

Yes, four. A non-voting MP chooses the select committee they sit on, and the party cannot remove them from it. Their written statements must be considered by the committee for the subject, which reports to the House. And the House hears them at least once a year as of right, on a matter they choose. A voting MP has none of these: the party decides their committees, and they speak when the party and the Speaker give them the call. These rights belong to the MP and not to the party, so that an electorate whose MP has no vote is still heard. More on this.

Doesn’t this create second-class MPs?

It gives MPs different roles, under one rule that applies to every party. A non-voting MP is an MP in every other way: sworn in, paid as an MP, with an electorate office, a full say in caucus and a seat on a select committee, and with rights a voting MP does not have. The alternatives are worse for the electorate. Germany’s rule leaves it with no MP at all. Today’s rule gives the MP’s party more votes than its party vote earned, at the expense of every other party’s voters. More on non-voting MPs.

Doesn’t it make the electorate vote worth less?

No. Under MMP the electorate vote chooses who represents an area, and the party vote decides how much of Parliament each party gets. Our fix keeps both votes doing those jobs. Every electorate still elects its MP, and that MP takes the seat. What changes is that winning more electorates than the party vote covers no longer adds votes in the House. Today it does, and that is how an overhang could decide who governs.

Do voters in an overhang electorate lose their say on laws?

Their MP does not vote in the House, but their own say is the same as everyone else’s. Every voter’s say on the balance of Parliament is their party vote, and under our fix every party vote counts the same. Their MP still takes part in caucus, where the party decides how to cast all of its votes, and is heard on a select committee and by the House. Under today’s rules voters for the other parties end up with less say, because the overhang party holds more votes than its party vote earned.

Couldn’t a party get round it with independents or a second party?

No. A candidate who wins an electorate without a party vote behind them sits without a vote: an independent who stands in the electorate only, or a party that declines the party vote. Votes in the House come only from party votes. So splitting a party into independents, or into an electorate party and a list party, brings it no extra votes. An independent who wants a vote can register as a party of one and ask for party votes, like any party.

Does the rule apply to conscience votes?

Yes. Only MPs who hold a vote take part in any vote in the House, including conscience votes. Otherwise the House would have more than 120 votes on those issues, and an overhang party’s MPs would carry more weight than its party vote earned.

Can MPs still cross the floor?

Yes. Every MP who holds a vote can vote against their party, just as now. In a party vote they cast their vote separately, and in a conscience vote they vote as they choose. Party leaders do not decide who holds the votes: that follows the party’s list, lodged before the election. A non-voting MP does not vote on any question, because their party already casts all the votes its party vote earned.

What happens if an MP leaves their party?

Under our draft, each party’s votes stay as the party vote set them at the last general election, so changing party cannot change the balance of Parliament. An electorate MP who leaves keeps the seat and gives up the vote, and cannot get a vote back in the same term, even by rejoining. A list MP who leaves the party leaves Parliament, and the next person on the party’s list comes in. The same applies to an MP expelled by their party, but a party can expel an MP only if two-thirds of all its MPs agree, voting and non-voting alike.

Are non-voting MPs paid, and does this cost more?

They are MPs in every other way: they take the oath, are paid as MPs, keep an electorate office and serve local people. Money and staff for a party’s work in Parliament follow its votes, not its headcount, so an overhang brings the party no extra resources. It costs no more than today’s rules, under which the extra MPs also sit and are paid. More about non-voting MPs.

Who would have a majority in 2026 with your fix?

Nobody, on election-night figures. The three parties of the caretaker government would hold 60 of the 120 votes, exactly half, which is what their party votes earned. Today they hold 67 of 131, because of the extra seats. Opportunity, with 7 votes, would hold the balance. We do not say who should govern; that is for the parties to work out from the votes the party vote gave them. See the figures.

When would the fix start to apply?

At the first general election after Parliament passes it. Under our draft the new rule comes into force on the day after the present Parliament ends, so it never applies in the middle of a term. If Parliament passes it during this term, it applies at the election due in 2029.

What about independent candidates?

An independent has two choices under our draft. They can stand in their electorate only, as now; if they win, they take the seat as a non-voting MP, because no party vote stands behind them. Or they can register as a “party of one” and ask for party votes across the country; the test is the same as for any party, 500 members. If their party vote earns a vote in the House, they hold it.

Can a party stand in electorates only?

Yes. Under our draft a party can decline the party vote before nominations close. The ballot paper then shows the words NO PARTY VOTE under its candidates’ names, so voters know. Its winners take their seats as non-voting MPs, because no party vote stands behind them, and the choice holds for the whole term.

What happens at a by-election?

The electorate gets its new MP, but each party’s votes in the House stay as the party vote set them at the last general election. A by-election cannot shift the balance of Parliament. If the winner was not on the party’s list at the general election, they join it at the foot; a candidate who loses is not added. An independent who wins a by-election sits as a non-voting MP. Today a by-election can shift the balance: the Northland by-election of 2015 took National from 60 seats to 59 and changed which laws the Government could pass. More on stable majorities.

Does this apply to the Māori electorates?

The Māori electorates stay as they are, and every Māori electorate MP keeps their seat and serves their electorate. The rule applies to every party alike: each party’s votes in the House match its party vote. On 2026 election-night figures, National would keep its 42 MPs and hold 35 votes, and Te Pāti Māori would keep its 5 MPs and hold 1 vote. This changes what the Māori electorates deliver in votes in the House, and it should be made with Māori agreement. Te Tiriti o Waitangi and the Māori electorates →

Would some MPs get a fraction of a vote?

No. Under our fix nobody holds part of a vote. Each party holds the whole votes its party vote earned, and its MPs hold them one each, in the order of the list the party lodged before the election. Some versions of the idea weight every MP’s vote instead, so that five MPs might each carry a fifth of a vote. We do not propose that. On 2026 election-night figures Te Pāti Māori would keep its 5 MPs and hold 1 vote, by the same rule that leaves National with 42 MPs and 35 votes.

Will Parliament get bigger?

No bigger than under today’s rules. When there is an overhang there are more than 120 MPs, as now, but the House has 120 votes. The one exception: if a party’s list runs out, a vote stays empty until the next election. The extra electorate MPs serve their electorates without a vote, and without extra funding or staff for their party.

Wouldn’t a bigger Parliament get rid of the overhang?

Not this year’s. One suggestion is 140 MPs, with 70 electorate and 70 list seats. On election-night figures, and if the electorate results stayed the same, a 140-seat Parliament would still have about 5 overhang seats. National’s party vote would earn it 41 seats against its 42 electorates, and Te Pāti Māori’s would earn it 1 seat against its 5. A party that wins several electorates on a very small party vote overhangs at any realistic size of Parliament. Our fix needs no extra seats: the House always has 120 votes, matched to the party vote.

Why this is fair · Non-voting MPs · The changes in law · Get involved