The path into law
What has to happen for the fix to become law, entrenched, in time for the next election: every step, who takes it, and how long we expect it to take.
In brief
- Seven steps, about 22 months. That is our estimate from the day an inquiry starts to the day the Governor-General signs the law.
- The Electoral Commission then needs time to prepare. We allow about a year before the election, due in 2029.
- So the work must start in early 2027. A start later than that puts the 2029 election at risk.
- Entrenchment takes no extra time. It travels in the same bill. What it adds is a higher bar: three-quarters of all MPs, public submissions, and no urgency.
The times on this page are our estimates. Parliament and the Government set their own pace. Each estimate rests on a rule or on what happened with recent electoral bills, and the table names it.
The steps at a glance
The steps, one by one
The clock starts when the House sets up an inquiry. “Running total” counts from that day.
| Step | Who | The rule, or the record | Our estimate | Running total |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. An inquiry by a select committee | The House sets it up. MPs from every party sit on it. | No rule sets the time. The Justice Committee’s inquiry into the 2023 election took about nine months. The Electoral Commission’s MMP review of 2012 took about eight and a half. The experts’ open letter asks for a report by mid-2027. | 6 months | 6 months |
| 2. The Government decides | Cabinet, on the advice of the Ministry of Justice. | The Government must answer the committee’s recommendations within 60 working days (SO 256). Cabinet approves the policy and gives the bill a place on its legislation programme. No drafting may start before that (Cabinet Manual 7.55). | 3 months | 9 months |
| 3. The bill is drafted and checked | The Ministry of Justice instructs. The Parliamentary Counsel Office drafts. The Electoral Commission advises. | The Parliamentary Counsel Office gives an average of 67 working days to draft a bill of 50 clauses and medium complexity. Then come consultation, the Bill of Rights check, and approval by the Cabinet Legislation Committee and Cabinet (Cabinet Manual 7.57, 7.70). | 5 months | 14 months |
| 4. Introduction and first reading | The Minister in charge of the bill, then the House. | The first reading comes no sooner than the third working day after the bill is introduced (SO 293). For recent electoral bills it came 5 to 21 days after. | 2 weeks | 14½ months |
| 5. Select committee and public submissions | A select committee. Anyone may make a submission. | The committee must report within six months, unless the House sets another time (SO 303). A time of four months or less can be debated (SO 298). Submissions are usually open for about six weeks. Entrenchment requires this step (SO 270). | 6 months | 20½ months |
| 6. Second reading, committee of the whole House, third reading | The House. The entrenching clause needs three-quarters of all MPs in the committee of the whole House. | The second reading comes no sooner than the third working day after the committee’s report (SO 304). Each later stage comes no sooner than the next sitting day (SO 307, 318). Entrenchment cannot be taken under urgency (SO 270). For recent electoral bills these stages took three weeks to three months. | 6 weeks | 22 months |
| 7. Royal assent | The Governor-General. | No rule sets the time. The Parliamentary Counsel Office says assent generally follows within seven days of the third reading. | 1 week | about 22 months |
SO means a Standing Order of the House of Representatives, 2026 edition. “Recent electoral bills” are the Electoral Amendment Acts of 2017, 2020, 2022 and 2025, the Electoral (Māori Electoral Option) Legislation Act 2022 and the Electoral (Integrity) Amendment Act 2018.
What runs alongside
The House changes its own rules
Much of the detail of the fix belongs in the Standing Orders: how a party’s votes are cast, and what a non-voting MP may do in the House. These are not part of the bill. The House adopts them itself, by a motion with notice (SO 6).
The House normally reviews its Standing Orders late in each term, through the Standing Orders Committee, and with the agreement of nearly all parties. The new rules take effect the day after Parliament is dissolved. In 2026 the committee reported on 21 September, the House adopted the changes on 23 September, and they took effect on 2 October.
The same timing suits the fix. Its Standing Orders can be adopted with the review of 2029, or earlier by motion, to take effect together with the new law. See our draft changes to the Standing Orders.
The Electoral Commission prepares
The Commission must change how it calculates and declares the result, apply the new rule for party lists, and explain the change to voters, parties and candidates. No published rule says how long it needs. The last two sets of electoral changes became law about ten to eleven months before the election they applied to. We allow a year.
The law comes into force
Under our draft, the fix comes into force on the day after the present Parliament is dissolved or expires. It first applies at the next general election. No sitting MP gains or loses a vote in the middle of a term. See clause 2 of the draft bill.
What entrenchment adds
We want the fix passed and entrenched. Entrenchment is a separate Part of the same bill, so it adds no step. Standing Order 270 sets three conditions, and each one shapes the timetable:
- Public submissions. A select committee must call for submissions on the entrenching clause and report on it. Step 5 cannot be skipped.
- No urgency. The clause cannot be considered while the bill is under urgency. Step 6 cannot be rushed.
- Three-quarters of all MPs. The clause must be carried by that majority in the committee of the whole House. This needs agreement across parties, which takes time to build. Step 1, the inquiry with every party at the table, is where it is built.
Our draft keeps the entrenching clause apart from the rest of the bill, in a separate Part (Part 2A) that is voted on separately. If it falls short of three-quarters, the fix can still pass by an ordinary majority on the same timetable, and the protection can be added later.
Counting back from the election
The next general election is due in 2029. Counting back from it:
| What must be done | By about |
|---|---|
| The law is passed and signed | the end of 2028 |
| The bill is introduced in the House | April 2028 |
| Cabinet approves the policy and drafting starts | late 2027 |
| The inquiry reports | mid-2027 |
| The inquiry starts | early 2027 |
These dates assume an election in late 2029. The timetable has little room to spare. Every month lost at the start is a month taken from the public’s chance to be heard, or from the Electoral Commission’s time to prepare.
What could make it faster or slower
Faster
- A short inquiry. The question is narrow, and the experts’ open letter has already set out the options. See what the letter asks for.
- A draft that already exists. Our draft bill and Standing Orders are not a Government bill, but they show the drafters every provision that must change.
- A select committee time of four months. Three of the recent electoral bills went from introduction to Royal assent in about five months, with four months at select committee.
Slower
- No inquiry is set up, or it is given a wider task than the overhang.
- The bill has no priority on the Government’s legislation programme.
- The select committee’s time is extended. The Business Committee may do this for any bill (SO 303).
- The bill waits between stages. The rules set the least time between stages, not the most. One recent constitutional bill waited seven months for its second reading.
The changes in law · Entrenchment · The fix in five points · Get involved