Save MMP!

Where it came from

The 1990s: New Zealand chooses MMP

Neither large party wanted MMP. A volunteer coalition held both to their promises of a referendum. In 1992 voters asked for change, and in 1993 they chose MMP, against a campaign that spent several times as much. The first MMP election was held in 1996.

The Electoral Reform Coalition

The Electoral Reform Coalition formed in 1986 around the Royal Commission’s report, which recommended MMP. Phil Saxby, one of its three founders, was its National Secretary for most of the years to 1993. Rod Donald was its national spokesperson from 1989 to 1993, and Colin Clark, a former general secretary of the Public Service Association, chaired it from 1991.

  • One issue, every party. It stayed on a single issue and reached across parties, unions, women’s groups and Māori leaders. Its office-holders kept clear of party politics.
  • Volunteers, not money. A small team in Wellington ran it, with branches around the country that largely ran themselves. It worked through a newsletter, public meetings, letters to the editor and submissions.
  • The Royal Commission’s plan, with one change. It kept to the Commission’s recommendations, except that it backed keeping the Māori electorates, which the Commission had proposed to abolish under MMP.

Sources: Phil Saxby, Getting it in proportion: how New Zealand chose MMP, submission to the British Columbia Citizens’ Assembly, 2004; Rod Donald, Proportional representation in NZ: how the people let themselves in, 2003 (archived copy).

1987 to 1990: two promises

In a televised leaders’ debate before the 1987 election, a question from the Coalition drew a promise from the Prime Minister, David Lange, of a binding referendum. He later said he had misread his notes. Labour then backed away: a select committee recommended keeping first past the post, and no referendum followed.

The Coalition made the broken promise its main argument. Before the 1990 election National promised a referendum too, and it won.

Source: NZHistory, The road to MMP: the Royal Commission.

1992 and 1993: two referendums

National chose two steps: a vote to guide Parliament first, then a binding vote on a fully written law.

19 September 1992: a guide for Parliament

Voters were asked whether to keep first past the post, and which of four other systems they preferred. On a turnout of 55 percent, 84.7 percent voted for change, and 70.5 percent chose MMP.

6 November 1993: the binding vote

Parliament passed the Electoral Act 1993, to take effect only if voters chose it. The binding referendum was held with the general election, on a turnout of about 85 percent. MMP won by 53.9 percent to 46.1 percent, and it led in all four Māori electorates.

Big money against the little people

The campaign against MMP, the Campaign for Better Government, was backed by business and professionally run, with heavy television advertising in the last week. There was no limit on spending, and it never published accounts. Estimates put its spending at several times the Coalition’s, which is put at between about $181,000 and $300,000. The money became the Coalition’s best argument: it asked voters to look at who was paying.

Sources: NZHistory, The road to MMP: putting it to the vote; Electoral Commission, A Royal Commission and two referendums; Philip Temple, MMP and my part in the downfall of First Past the Post, Newsroom, 2023; Rod Donald, 2003, as above.

1996: the first MMP election

Parliament grew from 99 to 120 members, and each voter now had two votes. The first MMP election was held on 12 October 1996. See how MMP works.

The Electoral Act 1993 followed the German design closely, with three differences. A party below 5 percent needs one electorate, where Germany asked for three. Each party has one list for the whole country. And the Māori electorates are part of the system. Like Germany at the time, New Zealand let a party keep its overhang seats, with nothing done to restore the balance.

Source: Electoral Act 1993, New Zealand Legislation.

The Coalition never wound up, because it had never been incorporated. It went on to campaign for the single transferable vote in local elections, and several of its people returned in 2010 to campaign to keep MMP.

What MMP delivered in New Zealand

  • Seats that match votes. On the Gallagher index, which measures the gap between votes and seats, New Zealand scored about 17 and 18 at the last two first-past-the-post elections. Under MMP it has scored between about 1 and 4.4. Lower is better.
  • Governments that need a majority of voters behind them. Since 1996 parties have governed together, in a coalition or with confidence and supply agreements. Only one party has won a majority alone, Labour in 2020.
  • A Parliament that looks more like the country. Māori, women and smaller parties sit in the House in numbers that first past the post never produced.

MMP came about because the public asked for it. Neither large party wanted the change. Voters did, and they got a referendum. The fix for the overhang will need the public to ask for it too.

Next: 2008 to 2011, keeping MMP