Where it came from
2008 to 2011: keeping MMP
In 2008 National promised a referendum on MMP. A volunteer campaign formed to keep it, and in November 2011 New Zealanders voted to keep MMP by 58 percent to 42. They were promised a review to improve it. The review reported in 2012, and Parliament left the rules as they were.
2008 to 2010: the promise of a referendum
In August 2008 National promised a referendum on MMP, and it confirmed the pledge in its electoral policy in September. In government it set the vote for the 2011 general election. The Electoral Referendum Act 2010 set the questions and the rules.
- Two questions. Part A asked whether to keep MMP. Part B asked which system voters would choose if it changed: first past the post, preferential voting, single transferable vote or supplementary member.
- A guide, not a decision. The vote was indicative. A majority for change would have led to a second, binding vote between MMP and the most popular alternative, at or before the 2014 election.
- A review either way. If voters kept MMP, the Act required the Electoral Commission to review how it worked. The overhang was one of the matters it had to look at.
- A spending cap. Each registered campaign could spend no more than $300,000 in the three months before the vote. The cap was added after public submissions asked for a level playing field.
Sources: Otago Daily Times, National’s policy confirms MMP referendum, 29 September 2008; Electoral Referendum Act 2010, New Zealand Legislation.
The Campaign for MMP
The Campaign for MMP was active by December 2009 and launched publicly on 14 February 2010. It brought together people from the 1992 and 1993 campaign that won MMP and a new generation of volunteers. In 2009 its later web address, keepmmp.org.nz, carried the material of the Electoral Reform Coalition, the group behind the 1990s campaign.
- Three spokespeople. Dr Sandra Grey of Wellington, a political scientist and union leader, was the lead spokesperson from the launch to 2013. Dr Philip Temple of Dunedin, writer and historian, had campaigned for MMP in 1992 and 1993. Lewis Holden of Auckland, chair of the Republican Movement, joined in September 2011.
- Volunteers and donations. It was run by volunteers, with regional groups and a nationwide coordinating group, and funded entirely by donations. It became an incorporated society, Campaign for MMP Incorporated, and registered as a promoter for the referendum.
- Support from many sides. Backers included the former All Black captain Anton Oliver, singer Don McGlashan, film maker Gaylene Preston, cricketer Glenn Turner, Archbishop David Moxon and nineteen New Zealand writers.
Two groups argued for change. Put MMP to the Vote, launched in 2010, favoured supplementary member. Vote for Change, launched in June 2011, argued that MMP gave voters too little power over list MPs and small parties too much. Shortly before the vote the Electoral Commission called one of its claims “factually incorrect, and misleading”.
Sources: Campaign for MMP, Nationwide pro-MMP group launched, Scoop, 15 February 2010; Campaign for MMP, About us, October 2011 (archived copy); Electoral Commission, Accurate information about referendum vital, 18 November 2011.
What the campaign said
- It is fair. Every vote counts equally, wherever you live. Under first past the post, votes in safe seats are wasted.
- Keep it and make it better. The slogan was “Let’s keep MMP & make it even better”. A vote to keep MMP secured an independent review, so voters unhappy with parts of it, such as electorate deals, were urged to keep it and fix it.
- Change means first past the post. The campaign argued that a vote for change would most likely lead to a run-off against first past the post.
- A Parliament that looks like the country. It pointed to more women, Māori, Pacific and Asian New Zealanders in the House under MMP.
It worked through stalls, public meetings, quiz nights and leaflets in English and te reo Māori. A national launch in Auckland on 28 October 2011 was followed the next day by local events from Whangārei to Dunedin. In the last fortnight it ran radio, newspaper and online advertising and delivered 700,000 leaflets.
Sources: the campaign’s website, Keep MMP, October 2011, and its releases A vote to keep MMP locks in an independent review, 3 October 2011, and Keep MMP campaign launched in Auckland, 28 October 2011 (archived copies); its expense return, below.
26 November 2011: the result
The referendum was held with the general election. In the official count, 57.8 percent of valid votes were to keep MMP, and 56 of the 70 electorates voted to keep it.
| Part A | Votes | Share of valid votes |
|---|---|---|
| Keep MMP | 1,267,955 | 57.8% |
| Change | 926,819 | 42.2% |
Source: Electoral Commission, official results (archived copy). In Part B, first past the post had the most votes among the alternatives.
Spending was the reverse of 1993, when the side against MMP spent far more. The Campaign for MMP declared $156,569 in referendum expenses and Vote for Change $79,048.
Sources: the expense returns of Campaign for MMP and Vote for Change (PDFs, Electoral Commission).
After 2011: the review that was shelved
The campaign stayed active through the Electoral Commission’s review of MMP and urged voters to take part. In October 2012 the Commission recommended a lower threshold, an end to the one-electorate rule and no extra seats for an overhang. In May 2013 the Government said there was no consensus and left the law as it was. See the 2012 review.
The campaign urged a rethink, saying the electoral system belongs to the people, not to Parliament. It then went quiet, and in 2016 the society was struck off the register.
Source: New Zealand Gazette, 2016, notice 2016-is3997.
A promise of reform is not reform. In 2011 voters kept MMP on the understanding that it would be improved. Without a plan to put the changes into law, they were shelved. This time we ask for the fix to be passed into law and entrenched. See why entrenchment matters.