Save MMP!

Our proposal

The fix

Representation can be gained through the electorate vote. Voting rights in Parliament are derived from the party vote alone.

We tolerate an overhang. We stop it from distorting proportionality.

Five points

  1. Every electorate keeps the MP it chose. No winner is turned away.
  2. Each party gets exactly the votes in Parliament its party vote earned. No more and no fewer.
  3. Extra electorate MPs still serve their electorates. If a party wins more electorates than its party vote earned, those MPs keep an office, work for local people and sit on select committees. They do not vote in the House. When a voting MP of the same party leaves Parliament during the term, the next of them in list order gains the vote. How non-voting MPs would work. The exact changes in law.
  4. Who votes is settled before the election, by the order of the party’s published list. The order cannot be changed afterwards.
  5. Parliament stays at 120 votes, shared out as the party vote decided, for the whole three years.

An overhang gains only one advantage: local representation. It brings the party no extra votes, and no extra party funding or staff. And a by-election cannot change any party’s votes in the House.

Why this is fair →

What changes for you

Nothing on the ballot paper. You still have two ticks, one for a local MP and one for a party, and you are free to give them to different parties. The difference is that your party vote now always counts.

Why not something else?

Remove overhang seats, keep 120 members

The extra electorate seats are taken out of other parties’ list seats. Parliament stays at 120, but the overhang party still has more seats than its party vote earned, and other parties’ voters pay for it.

Add seats to balance it out

Germany tried this and its parliament kept growing. On 2026 election-night figures it would have meant at least 146 MPs with the Māori electorates set apart, and with them counted in, no workable size at all.

Turn away some electorate winners

Germany does this now. Some of its cities have no local MP of their own. We think that price is too high.

Do nothing

Then the next election can be decided by extra seats again.

Our fix

Parliament keeps 120 votes, and every electorate keeps its MP.

See Germany’s three fixes and what went wrong with each.

An open letter from 46 electoral experts names this approach as one of four options for Parliament (see the experts’ open letter).

Others have proposed the same idea, among them a former Labour leader and a former member of Parliament’s electoral law committee (see what they said).

What exactly our rule does

Since the 2026 election, several people have suggested that a party with an overhang should vote with only what its party vote earned. Our proposal works this out in detail (as at November 2026):

  • Representation can be gained through the electorate vote. Voting rights in the House are derived from the party vote alone. Winning an electorate gives an MP a seat, and the electorate its voice. The MP also holds a vote only where the party vote has earned their party a vote for them to hold.
  • Every electorate winner takes their seat. No winner is turned away, and no seats are added.
  • A party’s votes in the House equal its party-vote entitlement, out of 120.
  • The votes are held in the order of the party’s list, lodged before the election. Where a party wins more electorates than its entitlement, the electorate winners who stand highest on its list hold the votes.
  • It applies to every vote in the House, including conscience votes, not only votes along party lines.
  • It holds for the whole term. A by-election does not change how many votes a party has.

Because the votes follow the list, an electorate candidate who is not on a party list can win a seat, and cannot hold a vote in the House. So a party must put every one of its electorate candidates on its list; no party’s winner is then left without a vote for being unlisted. An independent can stand in the electorate only, or register as a party of one and seek party votes.

The rule is set out in full, with the corner cases, in our paper, which we plan to publish here. The draft bill is already here: see the changes in law.

Why now, and why entrench it

This is mainly a change to the Electoral Act, in time for the next election. Voters have nothing new to learn.

A rule that a bare majority can bring in, a bare majority can also take away. So we want the fix passed and then entrenched: protected in law, as other core parts of our electoral system already are. Entrenchment: what it means

We recommend three steps:

  1. The law for the fix is drafted by the Parliamentary Counsel Office, which drafts Government bills, on the instructions of the Ministry of Justice and with the advice of the Electoral Commission.
  2. Parliament passes it this term, so that it applies at the next election, due in 2029. An ordinary majority is enough.
  3. Parliament entrenches it, by three-quarters of all MPs, this term if that majority can be found and otherwise as soon as it can.

The path into law: every step, and the time each takes →

And make it easy to vote. Under the fix, a party’s votes in the House come from the party votes actually cast. So we also ask the Crown to make it far easier for every voter to enrol, to stay enrolled and to vote: specifically Māori and young voters, and above all in rural areas. No voter should ever drop off the roll because they moved. Te Tiriti o Waitangi and the Māori electorates →

The MPs who would vote on it were elected under the present rules, and both sides gained from them. History shows that Parliament fixes voting rules when the public asks. MMP itself came about that way.

Why this is fair → · A fix for the future → · Entrenchment → · Non-voting MPs → · Te Tiriti o Waitangi → · Questions about the fix → · Get involved →