Side by side
Germany and New Zealand compared
The two countries use the same voting system. They differ in size, and in what stands behind Parliament. Those differences decide how much an overhang matters, and which fix can work here.
The two systems side by side
| Feature | Germany | New Zealand |
|---|---|---|
| Votes | Two: a local candidate and a party | Two: a local candidate and a party |
| What decides party strength | The party vote | The party vote |
| Formula | Sainte-Laguë | Sainte-Laguë |
| Threshold | 5 percent, or three electorates | 5 percent, or one electorate |
| Seats in parliament | 630 | 120 |
| Electorates | 299, which is 47 percent of the seats | 71, which is 59 percent of the seats |
| Party lists | One for each of the 16 states | One for the whole country |
| Minorities | Parties of national minorities are exempt from the threshold | Seven Māori electorates, on a separate roll |
| Where an overhang arises | List by list: in each state where a party wins more electorates than that state’s list has seats | Nationwide: when a party wins more electorates than its party vote earns across the whole country |
| Overhang | Ended in 2023: winners beyond the party’s share are not seated | Tolerated: Parliament grows, nothing is balanced |
| An electorate MP leaves | The next person on the party list takes the seat | A by-election |
| Term | Four years | Three years |
| Checks on parliament | A second chamber, a written constitution and a constitutional court | One House; no court can set a law aside |
| Changes to the rules since 2008 | Four laws and three court rulings | Two independent reviews, no change |
How proportional each has been
The Gallagher index measures the P in MMP: the gap between votes and seats. Zero is a perfect match, and lower is better. At its last two first-past-the-post elections New Zealand scored about 17 and 18.
| Germany | Index | New Zealand | Index |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1990 | 4.63 | 1996 | 4.38 |
| 1994 | 2.22 | 1999 | 2.99 |
| 1998 | 3.15 | 2002 | 2.54 |
| 2002 | 4.61 | 2005 | 1.13 |
| 2005 | 2.16 | 2008 | 3.84 |
| 2009 | 3.40 | 2011 | 2.38 |
| 2013 | 7.83 | 2014 | 3.72 |
| 2017 | 1.95 | 2017 | 2.73 |
| 2021 | 3.48 | 2020 | 4.15 |
| 2025 | 6.49 | 2023 | 2.63 |
| 2026 | about 3.6 |
Source: Michael Gallagher’s election indices, as used in our paper. The 2026 figure is our calculation from the election-night count.
- Both score low. In most elections each country is between 1 and 5, a small fraction of what first past the post produced.
- Germany’s two worst years were not about the overhang. In 2013 and 2025 many votes went to parties just under the 5 percent threshold, and those votes won no seats.
- The plain index hides an overhang. New Zealand scores about 3.6 for 2026, inside its usual range, because very few votes were wasted. Without the overhang it would have scored about 0.6, the most proportional result we have had.
To see what the overhang rule does by itself, the same election has to be counted under different rules. We did that for two German states.
Where they differ, and why it matters
Size
Germany has about 84 million people. New Zealand has a little over five million, about as many as one mid-sized German state. Germany’s parliament has 630 members and ours has 120.
One seat is therefore about five times as large a share of Parliament here as there. Seven overhang seats are 1.1 percent of the German parliament and 5.8 percent of ours.
Germany’s sixteen states are much closer to our size, and thirteen of them use MMP. See the German states and New Zealand compared.
The size of an electorate
A German electorate has about 200,000 voters. A New Zealand electorate has about 52,000. In land area it is the other way round: an average New Zealand general electorate is more than three times as large as a German one.
So the tie between an MP and an electorate is closer here, and an electorate with no MP of its own is a large area left without one. An electorate can also be won or lost on far fewer votes. In 2026, on election-night figures, National won its three closest electorates by 139, 456 and 1,092 votes. Had all three gone to Labour, the three governing parties would have held exactly half of Parliament, 64 of 128 seats, and not a majority.
The share of electorates
This difference is the least discussed, and it decides how easily an overhang arises. In Germany electorates are 47 percent of the seats. Here they are 59 percent, which leaves fewer list seats to balance them.
It was not designed that way. The Royal Commission proposed 60 electorates and 60 list seats. Parliament started with 65 electorates in 1996, and there are 71 today. The number follows a population formula in the Electoral Act, so the list seats have shrunk without anyone deciding that they should.
One German state has almost exactly our balance. Baden-Württemberg plans for 120 members and has 70 electorates. In March 2026 one party won 56 of them on 29.7 percent of the party vote, and the parliament grew to 157 members. Eight months later National won 42 of our 71 electorates on 29.2 percent. The same balance produced a large overhang at almost the same share of the vote (see the four state cases).
The Māori electorates
New Zealand guarantees seats: voters of Māori descent can choose the Māori roll, and seven Māori electorates cover the whole country. Germany guarantees nothing. It lets the parties of its national minorities into parliament below the threshold, and one such party holds a single seat.
Any fix for New Zealand has to say how it treats the Māori electorates. Under ours they stay as they are, and every Māori electorate MP keeps their seat.
What stands behind Parliament
A German government must get much of its law through a second chamber, where the governments of the 16 states vote. It works under a written constitution, and a constitutional court can strike its laws down. A majority made larger by an overhang still meets all three.
New Zealand has one House. A majority of one seat there can pass any law, and no court can set it aside. An overhang that creates such a majority weighs far more here than the same event would in Germany. The one counterweight is our short three-year term.
By-elections
When a German electorate MP leaves, the next person on the party’s list takes the seat. In New Zealand the electorate votes again, and under today’s rules a by-election can change the balance of Parliament during the term.
Nationwide here, list by list there
In New Zealand an overhang is a nationwide fact: a party overhangs when it wins more electorates than its party vote earns across the whole country. In German federal elections it arises list by list. Each party’s seats are fixed nationwide and then divided among its sixteen state lists. A party falls short wherever it wins more electorates in one state than that state’s list has seats.
At the 2025 election this happened in ten states at once, to four parties:
| Party | Electorate winners not seated | In which states |
|---|---|---|
| CDU | 15 | Baden-Württemberg 6, Hesse 5, Rhineland-Palatinate 3, Schleswig-Holstein 1 |
| CSU | 3 | Bavaria 3 |
| AfD | 4 | Brandenburg, Mecklenburg-Western Pomerania, Saxony and Saxony-Anhalt, 1 each |
| SPD | 1 | Bremen 1 |
Source: Deutscher Bundestag, 23 Erststimmensieger ziehen nicht ins Parlament ein, 2025 (in German); states assigned from the electorates.
Baden-Württemberg shows how it works. The CDU won 35 electorates there, and its state list was entitled to 29 seats. All 29 went to electorate winners, none to a list candidate, and six winners were left out.
- Who misses out is decided inside a state. A winner’s share of the local vote is compared only with the party’s other winners in the same state. A result that is enough in one state is not enough in another.
- The same party can have both at once: electorate winners without a seat in one state, and list MPs in another.
- The list is no way in where this happens, because no list seats are left in that state.
New Zealand has one list for the whole country, so none of this arises here: an overhang is counted once, nationwide. Our fix works at either level. It ties the vote in the House to what the party vote covers, wherever that is counted.
The same fault, a heavier weight
- An overhang comes more easily here, because electorates are a larger share of the seats.
- It weighs more here, because Parliament is one-fifth the size.
- Less stands in its way here, because there is no second chamber and no constitutional court.
At the national level in Germany an overhang never decided who governed. The nearest case was 1994, when it widened a government’s lead from two seats to ten. New Zealand’s overhang of 2026 is a larger share of Parliament than Germany’s was at its peak, none of it is balanced, and it is the difference between a majority and a tie.
Why Germany’s fixes do not fit New Zealand
Germany tried three fixes (see what happened with each). The two that worked on paper cost more here than there.
What turning winners away looks like
In 2025, in the northern electorate of Flensburg–Schleswig, Petra Nicolaisen of the centre-right CDU won with 26.5 percent of the electorate vote. She beat Robert Habeck of the Greens, at the time Germany’s Vice-Chancellor and one of the best-known politicians in the country, who took 22.6 percent.
She got no seat. Her party had won one more electorate in that state than its party vote covered, and hers was the lowest winning share among them. Habeck went to Parliament on his party’s list, and gave the seat up six months later.
Picture it here: the candidate who wins an electorate is told she has no seat, and the candidate she beat goes to Wellington. That is the price of Germany’s 2023 rule. It keeps Parliament proportional by taking the local MP away. Under our rule she would sit as the electorate’s MP, as a non-voting MP, and Parliament would stay proportional all the same.