Where it came from
2012 and 2013: the MMP review
Voters kept MMP in 2011, and the law then required a review of how it worked. The Electoral Commission reported in October 2012. It recommended removing the provision for overhang seats, with Parliament kept at 120. In May 2013 the Government said there was no consensus, and nothing changed.
The review
The Electoral Referendum Act 2010 told the Electoral Commission to review MMP if voters kept it. The Commission, chaired by Sir Hugh Williams, a retired High Court judge, ran the review through 2012. It published a proposals paper in August and its final report on 29 October 2012. More than 4,500 submissions were made. The Campaign for MMP urged voters to take part, so that the change would not be left to politicians.
Read the report: Report of the Electoral Commission on the Review of the MMP Voting System, 29 October 2012 (PDF, 2.3 MB, Electoral Commission). The overhang is discussed in paragraphs 1.55 to 1.63.
Sources: Electoral Referendum Act 2010, New Zealand Legislation; Campaign for MMP, We’ve selected it, now it’s time to perfect it, 13 February 2012 (archived copy); RNZ, Govt says no to MMP changes, 14 May 2013, for the number of submissions.
What it recommended
- End the one-electorate rule. A party should need the party-vote threshold to share in the list seats, and winning one electorate should no longer be enough. See the one-electorate rule.
- Lower the threshold from 5 to 4 percent, with the Commission to review it again after three elections.
- No extra seats for an overhang. If the one-electorate rule went, the provision for overhang seats should go too. A party would keep every electorate it won, and other parties would receive fewer list seats, so Parliament would stay at 120.
- Keep the balance of electorate and list seats, and consider fixing it at 60 to 40.
The Commission’s reason for the overhang change was size. With the one-electorate rule gone, the 2011 election would have produced six overhang seats and a Parliament of 126. It judged that such large overhangs were unlikely to be acceptable to the public and could cause problems for governing.
Who would gain, and who would pay. This is our reading, not the Commission’s. Under its rule the party with the overhang keeps every seat with a full vote, so it holds votes in Parliament that the popular vote did not give it. The seats to pay for them come out of the list seats of all the other parties. A party whose support is concentrated in electorates gains. A party whose supporters are spread across the country, and can win seats only through the party vote, pays. The rule does not favour large or small parties as such: in 2005, 2008, 2011, 2014 and 2023 the gain would have gone to a small party each time, and in 2026 most of it would go to a large one. What it discriminates against is the minority whose support is spread. Under our fix every party holds the votes its party vote earned, and no others.
It also said its changes did not alter the basic nature of the voting system, so they did not need a referendum. They needed a broad consensus in Parliament.
Source: the Commission’s report, linked above: the summary of recommendations (page 5), paragraphs 1.55 to 1.63 on the overhang, and “Implementation of our recommendations” (page 10) on a referendum.
May 2013: no consensus, no change
On 14 May 2013 the Justice Minister, Judith Collins, told Parliament that the Government would not change the law, because there was no consensus among the parties. Parliament never voted on the recommendations. RNZ reported it the same day: Govt says no to MMP changes (14 May 2013).
- The Prime Minister, John Key, said that major change to MMP needed either consensus or a vote of the people.
- Labour supported the 4 percent threshold and ending the one-electorate rule.
- The Greens and New Zealand First criticised the decision.
- The Campaign for MMP urged a rethink, saying the electoral system belongs to the people, not to Parliament.
The overhang provision stayed. An overhang of one seat followed in 2014, and of two seats in 2023. In 2026 the overhang reached 11 seats on election-night figures.
Sources: RNZ, Govt says no to MMP changes, 14 May 2013; Judith Collins, MMP changes impossible without agreement, Scoop, 15 May 2013; NZ Herald, Govt rejects recommendations to change MMP system, 14 May 2013; Campaign for MMP, Rethink urged on reluctance to progress MMP changes, 14 May 2013 (archived copy). For the overhangs, see every overhang since 2005.
The 2012 fix was a good one for its time. It would have kept Parliament at 120, at the cost of other parties’ list seats. Until then an overhang had been one or two seats. In 2026 the same method would take eleven seats from other parties. Our fix lets every electorate keep the MP it chose, and keeps the votes in Parliament proportional. See how the options compare.