About us
Our position
Representation can be gained through the electorate vote. Voting rights in Parliament are derived from the party vote alone.
These positions are a draft. They are the positions we have taken while working out the proposal. The SaveMMP committee has not yet signed them off, and the wording may change.
The lead position
The electorate vote chooses the local MP and gives that MP a seat. The party vote decides how many votes each party has in the House. An electorate MP holds a vote only where the party vote has earned their party a vote for that MP to hold. Every other position on this page follows from it.
It explains our treatment of the overhang. An overhang seat is representation the party vote does not cover. Under our fix it keeps the seat and carries no vote, because the party vote never earned one. Nothing is taken away.
No list, no vote. An electorate candidate who is not on a party list can win a seat, and cannot hold a vote in the House. Three rules keep that fair: a party must list every one of its electorate candidates; an independent may register as a party of one and seek party votes; and a by-election winner who was not on the list joins the foot of it.
On this page
MMP and the fault
What we want to keep, and what has gone wrong.
1. MMP is worth keeping
We want to keep MMP and fix one part of it. We do not defend the rules as they are, and we do not want MMP replaced. New Zealanders chose MMP in 1993 and confirmed it in 2011.
2. Proportionality comes first
The party vote decides how strong each party is in Parliament. That is the point of the whole system. A fix must deliver it whatever voters do with their two votes, and it must not depend on anyone’s restraint. Where simplicity and proportionality pull apart, proportionality wins: a rule that is simple but not proportional takes us back to FPP.
3. The overhang is a fault in the rules, not a charge against any party
Parties on both sides of Parliament hold overhang seats after 2026. Splitting your votes is every voter’s right, and nobody broke any rule. The fault is that the law sets no limit on the effect.
4. Since 2026 the overhang must be fixed
For thirty years the overhang was a fault New Zealand could live with. Since 2026 it is not. This is less a fix we want than a fix we need. We give five reasons:
- It decides who governs.
- It feeds itself, and it won’t stop.
- It was known for decades, and left alone.
- Nobody else will fix it.
- Left alone, it puts MMP at risk.
5. A fix has to meet four tests
- Keep the local promise: every electorate keeps the MP it chose.
- Keep Parliament proportional: each party votes with exactly what its party vote earned.
- Hold whatever voters do with their two votes.
- Last: entrenched, protected in law, so that a bare majority cannot undo it.
6. Figures are stated with their limits
Figures for 2026 are election-night figures until the official results are declared on 27 November 2026, and we say so each time. Putting past votes through a different rule shows how the rule works. It is not a forecast, because people would vote differently under different rules. We argue that our rule is sound from how it is built, not from simulations.
The fix
The rule itself.
7. The rule
Every electorate winner takes their seat. A party’s votes in the House equal what its party vote earned, out of 120. No winner is turned away, and no seats are added. In one sentence: every electorate keeps the MP it chose, and each party gets exactly the votes in Parliament its party vote earned, no more and no fewer.
8. We tolerate an overhang; we do not abolish or cap it
We tolerate an overhang. We stop it from distorting proportionality. Germany no longer tolerates an overhang. We tolerate it, and take away every reason to create one. An overhang gains only one advantage: local representation. It brings the party no extra votes, and no extra funding or staff. We never describe the fix as "abolishing" or "capping" the overhang.
9. Who votes is settled before the election, by the party list
A party’s votes are held in the order of its list, lodged before the election. Where a party wins more electorates than its party vote earned, the winners who stand highest on the list hold the votes. Nobody chooses after the election, and a party cannot move a vote from one MP to another during the term. A candidate must be on the list to hold a vote, and a party must put every one of its electorate candidates on its list. A short list is the party’s own risk.
10. The rule applies to every vote in the House
Only MPs who hold a vote take part in any vote in the House, including conscience votes. Otherwise the House would have more than 120 votes on those questions, and an overhang party’s MPs would carry more weight than its party vote earned.
11. Non-voting MPs are MPs in every other way
A non-voting MP takes the oath, is paid the same as any MP, keeps an electorate office and staff, and works for local people. The MP has a guaranteed place on a select committee of their own choosing, and can speak and move motions there. The MP can present written statements to the House, with no limit on how many, and the select committee must report on each. The MP can put written questions to Ministers, and can propose a member’s bill jointly with a voting MP of the party. In caucus the MP has the same vote as every other MP of the party.
The MP does not sit in the debating chamber, but has a permanent place in the gallery and may watch every sitting. The MP comes into the chamber to be sworn in, to make a first and a farewell speech, and to be heard on a matter at least once a year as of right, and more often when the House agrees. The MP does not vote in the House or in committee, and does not chair a committee. These rights are to be written into the Electoral Act, not left to Parliament’s own rules.
12. Certain offices need a vote
A Minister must be an MP with a vote, because Ministers answer to the House and a government stands or falls on votes there. The same applies to a Parliamentary Under-Secretary, the Speaker, the Deputy Speaker, an Assistant Speaker, the Leader of the Opposition, a party leader, a whip, and the chairperson or deputy chairperson of a select committee. Parties can place the people they want in these offices high on their list.
13. Money and staff follow the votes, not the headcount
The MP is paid as an MP. Every electorate keeps its office and staff, whether or not its MP has a vote. The party gains nothing: money and staff for a party’s work in Parliament follow its votes. Wherever a rule counts a party’s MPs, it counts its votes: for funding, speaking time, committee seats, oral questions and election broadcasting money. The fix costs no more than today’s rules, under which the extra MPs also sit and are paid.
14. Your two votes stay a free choice
Nothing changes on the ballot paper. You still have two ticks, and you are free to give them to different parties. The result is proportional however people use them. We do not claim that the fix will make voters align their two votes, and we do not say it makes MMP like FPP.
15. The status is temporary
Being a non-voting MP is decided afresh at every election. Within a term it can end early, when a vote passes down the list, and the voters can end it at the next election with their party votes.
During the term
What happens between elections.
16. This is a proposal for stable majorities
The majority the voters elect at the general election holds until the next one. A by-election or a change of party gives an electorate a new MP or an MP a new party; it cannot alter the balance of Parliament.
Each party’s number of votes is set at the general election and stays the same until the next one. The House has 120 votes throughout, so a majority is always 61, however many MPs there are. The majority you elect is the majority you get. We make no claim about a four-year term.
17. A by-election cannot shift the balance
The electorate gets its new MP. If the winner’s party already holds all the votes its party vote earned, the new MP sits without a vote. A by-election cannot alter proportional representation, so it cannot destabilise a government. A by-election winner who was not on the party’s list joins at the foot of it.
18. When a voting MP leaves Parliament, the vote stays with the party
The vote passes to the party’s next non-voting MP, in list order. If the party has none, the next person on its list comes in. If the list has run out, the vote stays empty until the next election; a party may not add names to its list.
19. When an electorate MP leaves their party, the seat goes with the MP and the vote stays with the party
An electorate MP who leaves their party stays in Parliament and goes on serving the electorate, without a vote. The vote stays with the party the voters gave it to, so changing party cannot change the balance of Parliament. An MP expelled by their party is treated the same way, but only if at least two-thirds of all the party’s MPs agree, voting and non-voting alike. A list MP who leaves the party, or is expelled, leaves Parliament, and the next person on the party’s list comes in.
Māori electorates, enactment and entrenchment
How the fix becomes law and stays law.
20. The Māori electorates stay, and the rule applies to every party alike
The Māori electorates stay as they are. Every Māori electorate MP keeps their seat and serves their electorate. Each party’s votes in the House match its party vote, with no exception for any party. This changes what the Māori electorates deliver in votes in the House, and it should be made with Māori agreement.
21. We intend to entrench MMP, including the Māori electorates
We intend to entrench MMP, including the Māori electorates. Their future is for Māori to decide.
22. Entrenchment covers the structure of MMP, not how votes are cast
Entrenchment should cover the system as a whole: a House of 120 votes, the two votes, a party’s right to register and put up a list, the sharing out of seats by the party vote, voting strength equal to the party vote, the vacancy rules, the rights of non-voting MPs, and the existence of the Māori electorates. It covers the rule that there is a threshold, but not its level: the percentage could still be lowered by an ordinary law. It adds no new lock on how votes are collected and counted, or on special voting; those stay with ordinary law.
23. Enact and entrench: an ordinary majority is the minimum, not the goal
A rule that a bare majority can bring in, a bare majority can also take away. We want the fix protected in law, as other core parts of the electoral system already are. If entrenchment cannot be won, the fix should still be passed by ordinary majority. The entrenching clauses should sit apart from the rest of the bill, so that their failure cannot sink it.
24. The fix needs the public to ask for it
The MPs who would vote on a fix were elected under the present rules, and both sides gained from them. Two independent reviews, in 2012 and 2023, recommended a change and Parliament did not act. History shows that Parliament fixes voting rules when the public asks; MMP itself came about that way. So we engage the voting public as well as members of Parliament.
Other proposals
The alternatives, and others working on the same problem.
25. We do not support removing overhang seats within a House of 120
Taking the extra electorate seats out of other parties’ list seats keeps Parliament at 120. But the overhang party still has more seats than its party vote earned, and other parties’ voters pay for it.
26. We do not support adding seats to balance, or a bigger Parliament
Germany added balancing seats and its parliament kept growing. For New Zealand in 2026 it would have meant at least 146 MPs with the Māori electorates set apart, and no workable size with them counted in. A larger Parliament of 140 would still have had about 5 overhang seats on the 2026 election-night figures, if the electorate results stayed the same. Our fix needs no extra seats.
27. We do not support turning electorate winners away
Germany has done this since 2023, and in 2025 it left 23 winners out of parliament. Some German cities have no local MP of their own. We think that price is too high for New Zealand, where voters expect the person they elected locally to be their MP.
28. Doing nothing is not an option
If the rule is left alone, the next election can be decided by extra seats again. Now that the effect is known, every party on every side has a reason to make use of it.
29. Supplementary member replaces MMP; our fix repairs it
Supplementary member would end the overhang by giving up a proportional Parliament. On the 2026 election-night votes it sits close to first past the post, not halfway. It gives a large bonus to whichever party wins the most electorates. Voters were offered it in 1992 and 2011 and turned it down both times. We state what is true about it and check the claims against the results.
30. We welcome the experts’ open letter and support its call for an inquiry
We welcome the letter "Keep the ’P’ in MMP" of 18 November 2026. We support its call for a select committee inquiry with every party at the table and the public heard. The letter lists four options and prefers none. We have taken its fourth option and worked it through. The signatories have not endorsed SaveMMP, and we say so wherever we cite the letter.
31. We credit others who proposed the same rule, and stand on the depth of our work
Since the 2026 election several people have suggested limiting a party’s votes to what its party vote earned. We do not claim to be first, and we credit others by the dated record. What should set our proposal apart is its maturity: the research, the corner cases, the documented changes, a draft bill and Standing Orders, the voices of the community, and named supporters. We say plainly that these measures are not all met yet: Māori have not been consulted, and support is still being sought.
The campaign
How SaveMMP conducts itself.
32. SaveMMP is independent of every party
SaveMMP is not part of any political party and does not support or oppose any party or candidate. The fix is about the rules, not about who won.
33. We use even-handed words
We say "overhang seats" or "extra seats", never "rorted", "stolen" or "cheating". We say "non-voting MP", never "second-class MP". We say "fix" or "small change", never "overhaul" or "new system". We use New Zealand terms: party vote and electorate vote, not list vote or candidate vote; FPP, not FPTP.
34. We say what is still open, and we correct mistakes
We list the points we have not settled and ask for them to be debated. Where we check other people’s claims, we give their words by link and our reading as ours, and we invite corrections. This website is not legal advice.
35. We do not use opinion-poll figures
We do not quote opinion-poll percentages or build graphics from them, because the sample and its bias are usually unknown. We use election results and referendum results.
36. Some subjects are outside our scope
For the 2026 election we take no position on campaign financing, on the changes to electoral law made for that election, or on possible voter suppression. They are separate issues. Our scope is the overhang and the proportionality of Parliament.
37. People are named only with their consent
The people and supporters behind SaveMMP are named publicly only with their consent. Membership of SaveMMP Incorporated, once formed, is for individuals only.
Further positions
Positions on the detail of the rule, on protection in law and on our own words.
38. The party-hopping provisions are repealed
An electorate seat belongs to the member who won it. A list seat belongs to the party vote that filled it. The vote always belongs to the party. Because a member who changes party can no longer change the balance of the House, the party-hopping sections of the Electoral Act (55A to 55E) are repealed. Their effect is kept for list MPs: a list MP who leaves the party, or is expelled by two-thirds of all its MPs, leaves Parliament, and the next person on the list comes in.
39. The rule first applies at the next general election
The rule never applies to the Parliament elected in 2026. It comes into force on the day after that Parliament ends, so it first applies at the next general election.
40. Special majorities are counted on voting members
Where the law asks for 75 percent of all members, that means 90 of 120 voting members.
41. Proxy votes continue
A voting member who is absent keeps the vote, and it is cast by proxy as now.
42. Select committee seats are shared by voting places
Parties share select committee seats according to their votes in the House. The guaranteed places of non-voting MPs come on top. Such an MP is not counted towards a committee’s quorum, and the number of non-voting MPs on any one committee is capped, with a place kept for every one of them.
43. Pay does not depend on having a vote
The Remuneration Authority may not set a different salary for an MP because the MP has no vote.
44. An independent is a party of one
A candidate without a party can register as a party of one, under the same test as any party: 500 members. The candidate then votes in the House only if that party vote earns a place: about 0.42 percent of the party vote, provided the candidate wins the electorate. A candidate may instead stand in the electorate only and, if elected, sit without a vote. A party therefore cannot get round the rule by standing its candidates as independents.
45. We do not support one fused vote, or more list seats, as the fix
A single vote that counts for candidate and party at once would end the overhang, but it takes away the voter’s free choice between person and party. Adding list seats or cutting electorates is also set aside. These are options 2 and 1 of the experts’ open letter.
46. More, smaller electorates can be considered once the rule is in place
We support more and smaller electorates on their merits, but only after the rule is in force, and not as a fix for the overhang.
47. We state the costs of our own proposal
The proposal creates two classes of member. It has no direct precedent. Non-voting MPs could be a regular feature, not a rare one. We say so.
48. One remedy for two kinds of overhang
The 2026 overhang has two sources: Te Pāti Māori’s four seats and National’s seven. The same rule applies to both.
49. Our other recommendations
We also recommend writing the principle of proportionality into the Electoral Act, stopping the share of list seats from shrinking as electorates are added, and giving the Electoral Commission power to treat linked parties as one.
50. An overhang brings no reward, and no electorate loses its MP
Our rule removes the reward for creating an overhang, for voters and for parties: however the two votes are used, each side gets the votes in Parliament its party vote earned. It keeps local representation: all 71 electorates keep the MP they chose. An overhang becomes a side effect of the electoral process, not a way to win the House. We make no forecast of how often an overhang will arise or of how people will vote; the rule works whatever they do.
51. Voters can pick the local candidate they prefer without distorting the proportions in Parliament
Under our rule the electorate vote does one thing: it chooses the local MP. A voter can choose their preferred candidate for electorate MP, whatever that candidate’s party, and the shares of the parties in Parliament still follow the party vote alone. The two votes stay free and separate, and using them for different parties is not penalised. We do not say that people will or should vote differently; the rule works however they vote.
52. The fix is keyhole surgery: one precise change, nothing else touched
We can fix democracy with keyhole surgery. The fault is treated where it sits, and everything else in MMP is left alone. It is not invasive: people vote exactly as they do today, and the two votes, the electorates and the House of 120 stay as they are. Recovery is quick: voters have nothing new to learn. And the outlook is good: every electorate keeps its MP, and Parliament’s 120 votes follow the party vote at every election to come. We remove no MP; we treat the inflammation and leave everything else alone.
53. The rules of the game should not belong to the winners
The rules that share out the seats decide who holds a majority. Today a bare majority of MPs can change them: MMP itself, the sharing out of seats, the threshold, the overhang rules and the Māori electorates are not among the six rules that section 268 of the Electoral Act protects. If a bare majority can rewrite the rules, the side that holds power can change them to keep it. That is true whichever parties govern. And a fix that a bare majority can undo is not finished.
54. Entrenchment needs three-quarters of all MPs
Adding a rule to the protected list is harder than passing an ordinary law. Under Parliament’s Standing Orders, a proposal that sets a 75 percent lock must itself be carried by 75 percent of all MPs, a select committee must first hear public submissions, and it cannot be passed under urgency. A referendum alone cannot add the protection. So entrenchment needs broad agreement across parties, which is right for the rules of the game.
55. We say "entrenchment", and explain it as "protected in law"
"Entrenchment" is the word we use as the heading and keyword, because it is a term people recognise. Where we explain it, we say "protected in law, so that a bare majority cannot undo it".
56. The overhang distorts the P in MMP
The P in MMP stands for proportional, as in proportional representation: each party’s share of Parliament follows its share of the party vote. The party vote is the popular vote: what the whole country voted for, with every vote counting the same wherever it was cast. Proportionality is the formal measure of how closely Parliament follows the popular vote, and that is why we defend it. In 1978 and in 1981 the system delivered an outcome against the popular vote, the voting public took exception, and New Zealand chose MMP. The overhang distorts proportionality. It gives a party more votes in the House than its party vote earned. Our rule restores the P and leaves the rest of MMP as it is.
57. We ask for three things: the fix this term, its entrenchment, and far easier enrolment and voting; we do not ask for a referendum
The campaign asks for three things: the fix; its entrenchment; and that the Crown make it far easier for every voter, and specifically Māori and young voters, to enrol, to stay enrolled and to cast their vote, above all in rural areas. In short: fix it, protect it, make it easy to vote. Under the fix every party vote cast counts in the House, so every voter should be able to cast one. We ask Parliament to pass the fix during this term, so that it is in force for the next election, and to entrench it by three-quarters of all MPs. We do not ask for a referendum on the fix. A referendum is not needed to pass it, cannot by itself entrench it, and one held with the next election would come too late for that election. If voters are asked about MMP in a referendum called by others, we will make our case there.
58. Three steps: the law is drafted, Parliament passes it this term, Parliament entrenches it
We recommend three steps. First, the Parliamentary Counsel Office, which drafts Government bills, drafts the law for the fix, on the instructions of the Ministry of Justice and with the advice of the Electoral Commission. Second, Parliament passes it during this term, so that it is in force for the general election due in 2029; an ordinary majority is enough. Third, Parliament entrenches the rules that share out the seats, by three-quarters of all MPs, in the same term if that majority can be found and otherwise as soon as it can. None of these steps needs a referendum.
59. In caucus, all of a party’s MPs are equal, voting and non-voting
A non-voting MP takes part and votes in the party’s caucus on the same terms as every other MP of the party, on every matter, including discipline. Caucus is where a party decides how its votes in the House are cast, so this is where a non-voting MP’s electorate is heard. The draft law makes it a right. A party can expel one of its MPs only if at least two-thirds of all its MPs agree, voting and non-voting alike.
60. We strengthen the role of the non-voting MP wherever we can
Where a point about non-voting MPs is still to be settled, we choose the answer that gives them more: more voice, more rights, more standing. The offices that carry a vote in the House stay with voting MPs.
In four respects a non-voting MP already has more than a voting MP. They choose the select committee they sit on. The party cannot remove them from it. Their written statements must be considered by the committee for the subject, which reports to the House. And the House hears them at least once a year as of right, on a matter they choose. These rights belong to the MP and not to the party.
71. We keep the one-electorate rule; nobody comes in on votes the party vote did not earn
A party that wins an electorate has its party votes counted, even below the threshold. It then holds exactly the votes its party vote earned: no more because of the electorate, and no fewer. Anyone who comes into Parliament behind an electorate winner, the so-called coat-tail, is there because party votes put them there. Two reviews proposed to end coat-tailing by setting such a party’s votes aside and letting its electorate winner sit and vote all the same. That would be a vote in Parliament the party vote did not earn, which is what our fix removes. We do not claim to have settled the wider complaint: a party with an electorate still comes in below the threshold when a party without one does not. That is a question about the threshold, and it can be decided separately.
72. The system must work for a diverse Parliament and for voters who use both votes freely
New Zealand needs an electoral system that is geared to a much more diverse political spectrum, and prepared for voters to use their voice in a much more nuanced way than its designers expected. A rule that holds only while two large parties share the electorates and the party vote between them is not enough. Our fix assumes nothing about how many parties there are, how large the largest is, or how electors use their two votes.
Te Tiriti o Waitangi and protections for Māori
What the fix means for Māori, what comes with it, and where we stand on other options.
61. No change without protections for Māori
We will not ask for the fix on its own. It comes with measures that protect the rights of Māori, and it should be made only with Māori agreement. Without those protections it should not be made.
62. Make it far easier to enrol and vote
The Crown must make it dramatically easier for every voter, and specifically Māori and young voters, to enrol, to stay enrolled when they move or their details change, and to cast their vote, above all in rural areas, where getting to a voting place can be the hardest part. The Waitangi Tribunal has said the Crown should take special steps to encourage Māori to take part in elections. For Māori voters, the measures should be designed with Māori. This, not giving some votes more weight than others, is our answer to the turnout gap.
63. The effect is measured and published after every election
After every general election the Electoral Commission reports, in public, on turnout on each roll, on the Māori roll’s share of the population and of the party votes cast, and on how many MPs from Māori electorates hold a vote.
64. Māori as partners in the reform
A select committee hearing submissions is not the same as working with the Treaty partner. We ask that the Crown work with Māori directly before a bill goes to Parliament. Who gives Māori agreement, how and when, is for Māori to say, not for us.
65. A place on the Māori Affairs Committee
A non-voting MP from a Māori electorate can choose a place on the Māori Affairs Committee, whatever the limit on other committees.
66. A review after the first election under the fix
After the first general election under the fix, an independent review, carried out with Māori, looks at what the fix has done to Māori representation. It is presented to the House, and the Government must respond.
67. We oppose fewer Māori electorates, or none
Some have proposed abolishing the Māori electorates, and some reforms would cut their number as a side effect. We oppose both. We want their existence protected in law, and their future left for Māori to decide.
68. We do not propose weighting votes, a separate Māori share, or an exemption
We do not propose counting party votes on the Māori roll for more, or giving the Māori roll a fixed share of the votes in the House shared out by its own party votes: both would make some votes count more than others. Nor do we propose leaving the Māori electorates out of the rule: a rule that applies to some parties and not others would keep the double weight of a split vote for one roll, and invite others to look for their own exemption. These are real options for Māori to raise. If Māori ask for them, they must be part of the conversation.
69. Where we take no position
We take no position on an eighth Māori electorate: the number follows the Māori electoral population. We do not oppose a Parliamentary Commissioner for Te Tiriti o Waitangi, which Te Pāti Māori proposes; it is not our proposal. Wider constitutional change based on Te Tiriti, as in Matike Mai Aotearoa, is a much larger question than ours, and the campaign takes no position on it.
70. We state the concerns and how we meet them; past figures are not a forecast
Where our fix may fall short, for Māori above all, we say so plainly, with the figures and their limits, and we say what we would do about it. We do not predict how people will vote from how they voted before. Fewer people have voted on the Māori roll, so under the fix the party votes cast there count for less than the Māori electorates’ share of the population. Under the fix every extra party vote counts, which gives people a new reason to vote.
Points of detail we have settled
Working out the draft law raised many questions of detail. These are the answers we have given. The exact wording is in the changes in law.
Who holds the votes
- A party’s votes are held in the order of its list, as lodged before the election and fixed for the term. They are not given by a winner’s own result, and the order cannot be changed after the election.
- Every electorate candidate of a party must be on its list.
- The largest party not in Government is measured by its votes in the House, not by its number of MPs.
- A party may decline the party vote by signed notice before nominations close. The ballot paper then shows NO PARTY VOTE under its candidates’ names, and its winners sit as non-voting MPs.
The rights of a non-voting MP
- In caucus, all of a party’s MPs are equal, voting and non-voting, as a right in law.
- A non-voting MP chooses the select committee they sit on and is appointed with its other members. These places are extra, and capped per committee; every non-voting MP must have a place.
- Written statements go to the select committee that deals with the subject, which must consider each one and report to the House. There is no limit on how many an MP may present.
- The House hears each non-voting MP at least once a year as of right, and more often when it agrees. Voting MPs may put questions. Standing Orders set a minimum time. The Speaker decides an independent MP’s request.
- A non-voting MP may put written questions to Ministers, and may propose a member’s bill jointly with a voting MP of the party. The bill counts as that MP’s one entry in the ballot, so a party with extra MPs gets no extra entries.
- A non-voting MP does not sit in the debating chamber, and has a permanent place in the gallery. Attending their select committee meets the duty to attend.
- A non-voting MP is paid the same as a voting MP.
Offices that need a vote
- Minister, Parliamentary Under-Secretary, Speaker, Deputy Speaker, Assistant Speaker, Leader of the Opposition, party leader and whip.
- The chairperson and deputy chairperson of a select committee.
- The MP a party names to speak for it on the House’s business.
- Only voting MPs nominate and vote in the election of the Speaker. The Speaker’s own vote is cast with the Speaker’s party, as now.
During the term
- An MP expelled by the party is treated as leaving it, but only if at least two-thirds of all the party’s MPs agree, voting and non-voting alike.
- A list MP who leaves the party, or is expelled, leaves Parliament. An electorate MP keeps the seat without a vote.
- An MP who has left the party cannot get a vote back in the same term, even by rejoining.
- A party’s candidate who wins a by-election without having been on its list joins the list at the foot. A candidate who loses is not added, and no other name can be added during the term.
- If a party’s list runs out, the vote stays empty until the next election. Parliament then has fewer than 120 votes for that time.
- A non-voting MP who gains a vote during the term is recognised by the House as a voting MP from then on.
Independents and new parties
- An independent who wants party votes registers as a party of one, with 500 members like any party. Otherwise they stand locally and, if elected, sit as a non-voting MP.
- An independent, or a candidate of a party with no votes in the House, who wins a by-election sits as a non-voting MP.
- A new party formed during the term needs six voting MPs to be recognised.
Counting in the House
- Where the law asks for 75 percent of all MPs, it means 90 of the 120 votes.
- Counted in votes, not in MPs: the 61 supporters that bring in a member’s bill without the ballot, the share of oral questions, the number present to suspend Parliament’s rules without notice, and the size of a party wherever a rule depends on it.
- Election broadcasting money has regard to a party’s voting MPs.
The Māori electorates
- Winners of Māori electorates are treated like all electorate winners. There is no special rule.
- The existence of the Māori electorates is on the protected list. Their number, boundaries and future are not affected.
Protection in law
- The protecting clauses are a separate Part of the same bill, voted on separately, so that the fix can pass if three-quarters cannot be found.
- Protected: the House’s members, the two votes, party lists, a party’s right to register with 500 members, the party of one, the sharing out of seats by the party vote (with the rule that there is a threshold, but not its level), voting strength, the rule that votes and majorities are counted in voting MPs, the rights of non-voting MPs, and the existence of the Māori electorates.
- Not protected: how votes are collected and counted, enrolment, campaign finance, and the procedure of party registration.
- The protecting section is not made to protect itself. That has never been done in New Zealand and we do not propose it.
When it starts
- The rule comes into force on the day after the present Parliament is dissolved or expires, so it first applies at the next general election.
Some points are still open, and a lawyer has not yet reviewed the draft. We list the open points on the law pages.
The fix · Non-voting MPs · Entrenchment · Frequently Asked Questions · About SaveMMP