Save MMP!

Where it came from

MMP before 1990

MMP began in West Germany in 1949, as a compromise. For forty years no other country used it. In New Zealand, two elections won by the party with fewer votes led to a Royal Commission, which in 1986 recommended MMP on the German model. This page follows the story to 1990.

Before 1949: two systems, two complaints

The Germans who wrote the first election law after the Second World War knew two voting systems at first hand, and each had a fault.

Party lists only

Germany’s Weimar Republic (1919 to 1933) shared out seats strictly by party vote. It was proportional, but voters chose parties and not people, and eleven to fifteen parties sat in parliament after every election.

Local MPs only

Britain used first past the post. Every area had its own MP, but a party’s seats could be far from its share of the vote. In 1951 the party with fewer votes won a majority.

After 1945 many Germans blamed the list system for the collapse of their first democracy. Historians have since questioned that view, but it shaped what came next.

Sources: Deutscher Bundestag, 10. Mai 1949: Erstes Bundeswahlgesetz beschlossen (in German); House of Commons Library, UK Election Statistics: 1918 to 2023.

1949 to 1956: Germany builds the compromise

When West Germany wrote its election law in 1948 and 1949, the two largest conservative parties wanted local MPs elected the British way. The Social Democrats and the smaller parties wanted proportional representation. Neither side had the numbers to win, so the law gave each a part of what it wanted.

  • 1949: local MPs inside a proportional parliament. About 60 percent of the seats were electorates and 40 percent came from party lists, shared out so that the overall result matched the vote. Voters had one vote, which counted for the candidate and for the party. A party needed 5 percent of the vote in one state, or one electorate.
  • 1953: two votes. Voters now had one vote for a local candidate and one for a party, as New Zealanders have today. The 5 percent threshold applied to the whole country.
  • 1956: the system made permanent. A party below 5 percent now needed three electorates, not one, to share in the list seats.

British officials had a hand in it. In 1946 they agreed an election law for local councils in the British zone of occupied Germany, under which some councillors were elected in local seats and others from party lists. Two German states built on that law, and the federal parliament took over the design.

Sources: Deutscher Bundestag, 10. Mai 1949: Erstes Bundeswahlgesetz beschlossen, and Datenhandbuch, chapter 1.1: Wahlgesetze und Wahlrechtsregelungen (PDF, both in German); Fabian Michl and Johanna Mittrop, Abschied von der Personenwahl, Verfassungsblog, 17 January 2023 (in German), on the 1946 British zone law.

1956 to 1990: forty years alone

For four decades MMP was a German peculiarity. West Germany’s record of stable government and proportional results then made it attractive to reformers elsewhere.

New Zealand was the decisive case, because it was an established democracy that chose MMP on its merits. Others followed in the 1990s and after, among them Scotland, Wales, Bolivia and Lesotho.

1978 to 1990: New Zealand looks for a better system

Until 1993 New Zealand voted under first past the post. Three things turned voters against it.

  • The party with fewer votes could win. In 1978 and again in 1981, Labour won the popular vote: more votes than National across the country. National won more seats and stayed in government. Voters took exception to a result that went against the popular vote.
  • Smaller parties were shut out. In 1981 Social Credit won about a fifth of the vote and two seats.
  • Governments faced few checks. With one House and no coalition partner, a government could make sweeping changes it had not announced before the election. Labour did so after 1984, and National would do so after 1990.

1986: the Royal Commission

The Royal Commission on the Electoral System reported in 1986, under the title Towards a Better Democracy. It compared voting systems and recommended MMP on the German model.

Neither large party wanted the change. A campaign outside Parliament kept the report alive, and by 1990 both large parties had promised voters a say.

Sources: NZHistory, The road to MMP: first past the post and The road to MMP: the Royal Commission; Electoral Commission, Report of the Royal Commission on the Electoral System 1986, the full report as scanned chapters.

Next: the 1990s, when New Zealand chose MMP