Save MMP!

The fault in the rules

The overhang

An overhang is what happens when a party wins more electorates than its party vote earned. When it is large, the seats in Parliament no longer match the party vote.

What an overhang is

Under MMP your party vote decides how many of the 120 seats each party has earned. A party’s electorate MPs are counted first, and list MPs make up the rest. See how MMP works.

Sometimes a party wins more electorates than the seats it earned. Say its party vote earned it 6 seats and it wins 9 electorates. Under today’s rules:

  • The party keeps all 9 electorate MPs, and all 9 vote in the House.
  • Every other party keeps the seats it earned.
  • Parliament grows from 120 to 123 members for that term. The 3 extra seats are the overhang.

How it comes about

An overhang arises when a party’s share of the electorates is much larger than its share of the party vote. That can happen in two ways.

The two votes go different ways

Many voters give a party’s candidates their electorate vote and give their party vote to another party. The party keeps winning electorates while its party vote falls. This is vote-splitting, and it is every voter’s right.

Many wins on a modest vote

An electorate is won by the candidate with the most votes, even if that is well under half. Where several parties compete, one party can win most electorates on a minority of the vote, with no vote-splitting at all.

New Zealand’s numbers make an overhang easier to reach than it used to be. The number of electorates has risen with the population while Parliament stayed at 120 seats. There are now 71 electorates and only 49 list seats left to balance them.

Source: Electoral Commission, 2026 General Election: preliminary results: 71 electorates in 2026.

What the overhang protects

The overhang rule is not a mistake. It was put there for good reasons, and we want to keep them.

  • The local promise. The candidate who wins your electorate becomes your MP, without conditions.
  • Other parties’ seats. No party loses a seat because another party won too many electorates.
  • Seats that do not depend on a party vote. The Māori electorates and independent candidates need a rule that lets an electorate winner sit whatever the party vote says.

We keep the spirit of the rule

The rule protects local choice. If voters return an MP who has left their party, stands as an independent or leads a new party, that MP takes the seat, even when the MP’s party won few party votes or none.

Organised vote-splitting turns that protection into a way to win extra votes in the House. Gerry Brownlee, the outgoing Speaker, said of it: “I think that is a real perversion of what MMP was supposed to be about.” (Duncan Garner, 15 November 2026)

Our fix keeps the protection and takes away the reward. Every electorate winner still takes the seat. An overhang brings no extra votes in the House, so there is nothing to gain by engineering one.

What the overhang costs

  • Seats no longer match votes. The party with the overhang holds a larger share of Parliament than its party vote earned, and every other party a smaller one.
  • Some votes count twice. A voter whose electorate vote elects an extra MP, and whose party vote counts in full for another party, helps to fill two seats. Other voters help to fill one.
  • The party vote loses its value. Once a party has an overhang, a further party vote for it adds nothing. Its supporters do better to give that vote to an ally, which makes the overhang larger still.
  • It can decide who governs. When an election is close, the extra seats can create a majority that the party vote did not.
  • Parliament grows. Each overhang seat is one more MP than the 120 the law provides for.

Small for thirty years, then large

From 1996 to 2023 an overhang was one or two seats, held by a very small party. It never decided who governed. See every overhang since 1996.

In 2026 the overhang reached 11 seats on election-night figures, which is 8.4 percent of Parliament’s 131 members. It turned one side’s exact half of the seats into a majority, and could decide who governs. See what went wrong in 2026.

For comparison, Germany’s constitutional court has accepted an overhang without any correction only up to about 15 seats in a parliament of about 600, which is 2.5 percent.

Sources: Electoral Commission, 2026 General Election: preliminary results (election-night figures); Federal Constitutional Court of Germany, judgment of 25 July 2012, 2 BvF 3/11 (in English).

An overhang does little harm when it is rare and small. It becomes a fault when it is large enough to change who has a majority. The rule is the same in both cases. Nothing in today’s law tells them apart.

Why the overhang must be fixed

2005 to 2026: New Zealand and its overhang

New Zealand’s first overhang came in 2005. It happened at five of the ten elections from 1996 to 2023, and it was always small.

ElectionParty with extra seatsExtra seatsMembers of Parliament
2005Māori Party1121
2008Māori Party2122
2011Māori Party1121
2014United Future1121
2023Te Pāti Māori2122
2026National 7, Te Pāti Māori 411131

After the 2023 election a by-election took Parliament to 123 members. The 2026 figures are from the election-night count.

Sources: Independent Electoral Review, final report, paragraph 4.90, for 2005 to 2023 and the by-election; Electoral Commission, 2026 General Election: preliminary results, for 2026.

Two reviews, no reform

Independent bodies examined the MMP rules twice, and both times Parliament left the rules as they were.

2026: the overhang could decide

Until 2026 an overhang was one or two seats, held by a very small party. In 2026 it reached 11 seats, a large party held most of them, and on election-night figures the extra seats turned one side’s exact half of the seats into a majority, and could decide who governs. See what went wrong in 2026.

The result also brought back an old memory. On election-night figures Labour won more party votes than National, and National has more seats, 42 to 36, as in 1978 and 1981. It is not the same as then: the three parties of the caretaker government together won 49.9 percent of the party vote, and the extra seats turned that half into a majority. But it is the fault New Zealanders chose MMP to end, and that explains why the result has been so widely reported and argued over.

1990 to 2025: Germany and its overhang

Germany met the overhang first. For forty years it was rare. After 1990 it became a regular feature, because the two large parties lost votes to newer parties and still won most electorates.

  • 2008 and 2012: the court steps in. Germany’s constitutional court twice struck down the rules. In 2012 it held that an overhang with no correction is acceptable only up to about 15 seats.
  • 2013, the first fix: add seats to balance it out. Parliament now grew until every party’s seats matched its party vote. Planned at 598 members, it had 631 after the 2013 election and 709 after 2017.
  • 2020, the second fix: a partial brake. Up to three overhang seats were left uncorrected, to slow the growth. It did little. The parliament elected in 2021 had 736 members, the largest yet.
  • 2023, the third fix: turn winners away. A new law fixed parliament at 630 seats. A party’s electorate winners now take their seats only as far as its party vote covers them. At the 2025 election, 23 candidates who won their electorates did not become MPs.

See Germany’s three fixes in detail. Germany is still arguing about it. The government formed in 2025 promised to find a way for every electorate winner to sit again, and has not yet agreed on one.

Sources: Federal Constitutional Court of Germany, judgment of 3 July 2008 (in German) and judgment of 25 July 2012 (in English); Deutscher Bundestag, Datenhandbuch, for the size of each parliament, and 23 Erststimmensieger ziehen nicht ins Parlament ein, 2025 (in German); the Federal Returning Officer, 2025 results (in German).

Two countries, one fault

Germany and New Zealand built the same system and met the same fault. Germany applied three fixes in ten years. It added seats, and its parliament kept growing. It tried a partial brake, which did little. It then turned electorate winners away, and is still arguing about that. New Zealand’s two reviews proposed taking the extra seats from other parties.

See the two systems side by side.

Our proposal learns from all of these. Every electorate keeps the MP it chose, Parliament keeps 120 votes, and each party votes with exactly what its party vote earned. See why we propose something else.

MMP came about because the public asked for it. Neither large party in New Zealand wanted the change in the 1980s. Voters did, and they got a referendum. The fix for the overhang will need the public to ask for it too.

What can be done about it

Countries that use MMP have tried four answers. Each gives something up.

Tolerate it

New Zealand’s rule today. The local promise is kept, and proportionality is lost whenever the overhang is large.

Take the seats from other parties

What New Zealand’s reviews of 2012 and 2023 recommended. Parliament stays at 120, but the party still has more seats than it earned, and other parties’ voters pay for it.

Add seats for everyone else

Germany did this from 2013. Proportionality was restored, and in 2021 its parliament had 138 more members than planned.

Turn some winners away

Germany’s rule since 2023. Parliament is proportional and fixed in size, and some electorates have no local MP of their own.

Our fix

Every electorate winner sits. Each party votes in the House with exactly the votes its party vote earned.

See what happened with each of Germany’s fixes.

We tolerate an overhang. We stop it from distorting proportionality.

An overhang gains only one advantage: local representation. It brings the party no extra votes, and no extra party funding or staff.

See the fix