Save MMP!

Checking the claims

Supplementary member: would it fix MMP?

Some senior politicians say New Zealand should answer the overhang by switching to a supplementary member system. We checked what is said for it against the election results.

What is being proposed

Under supplementary member, often shortened to SM, you would still have two votes. The difference is in what the party vote decides. Today it decides each party’s share of the whole Parliament. Under SM it would only share out the list seats. A party would keep every electorate it wins and add its list seats on top.

Since the 2026 election it has been put forward by Nick Smith (Q+A, 15 November), Gerry Brownlee (RNZ, 17 November), Paul Goldsmith (Herald, 14 November) and Chris Finlayson (Cross Party Lines, 17 November). Mr Smith’s example was 70 electorates and 50 list seats. Mr Brownlee’s was 60 and 60.

What is true about it

  • There would be no overhang. Parliament would always have 120 MPs.
  • It is simple. The rule fits in one sentence.
  • Every MP would have a vote.
  • Electorate contests would matter more, because every electorate would change the balance of Parliament.

The question is what it gives up to get there.

What the 2026 votes would have produced

We put the 2026 election-night votes through three sets of rules: today’s MMP, our fix, and supplementary member with today’s 71 electorates and 49 list seats.

PartyParty voteMMP today: MPs of 131Our fix: votes of 120Supplementary member: MPs of 120
Labour29.4%363636
National29.2%423556
Green13.3%16169
ACT10.9%13136
NZ First9.8%12125
Opportunity6.0%773
Te Pāti Māori0.6%515

With 29.2 percent of the party vote, National would hold 56 of 120 seats, which is 46.7 percent of Parliament. That is 21 seats more than its party vote earned. Four parties would lose about half their MPs.

This shows how each rule works. It is not a forecast: people would vote differently under different rules.

The claims, checked

“It is a halfway house between first past the post and MMP.”

Nick Smith on Q+A; Paul Goldsmith in the Herald, in similar words.

The usual measure of how far a Parliament departs from the party vote is the Gallagher index, where zero is a perfect match. MMP elections have scored between about 1 and 4.4. The last two first-past-the-post elections scored about 17 and 18. On the 2026 votes, supplementary member scores about 14.7.

Our reading: it sits close to first past the post, not halfway.

Parliament would still be proportional most of the time.

Gerry Brownlee’s view on Nine to Noon, 17 November, in our summary of what he said.

We ran the last three elections. In each one the party with the most electorates would have held far more of Parliament than its party vote earned: 60 percent of the seats on 50 percent of the vote in 2020, 52.5 percent on 38.1 percent in 2023, and 46.7 percent on 29.2 percent in 2026.

Our reading: the figures do not support it for any of the three elections.

It would end the overhang.

Nick Smith and Gerry Brownlee.

True. There is no overhang because the rules stop comparing a party’s electorates with its party vote. The extra seats are still there. In 2026 National’s 7 seats above its share would become 21.

Our reading: true, by making the extra seats permanent.

It would end the gaming of the system.

Nick Smith on Q+A, in our summary.

Organised vote-splitting would lose its purpose. But when electorates decide who governs, the pressure moves to the electorate vote, as it did under first past the post: voting for the candidate who can win instead of the one you prefer, parties standing aside for each other, and arguments over where the boundaries are drawn.

Our reading: it moves the gaming to the electorates.

A lower threshold could look after the small parties.

Suggested by Gerry Brownlee on Nine to Noon, in our summary.

The threshold decides which parties share the list seats. It does not make more list seats. On the 2026 votes the Greens would fall from 16 MPs to 9, ACT from 13 to 6, NZ First from 12 to 5 and Opportunity from 7 to 3, and every one of them is already above the threshold. Both Mr Smith and Mr Brownlee accepted that smaller parties would have fewer MPs.

Our reading: a lower threshold would not give those seats back.

Who gains

Supplementary member gives a large bonus to whichever party wins the most electorates. Here are the last three elections, with the electorates as they were won and the rest of the 120 seats shared out by party vote.

ElectionMost electoratesIts party voteIts share of Parliament under MMPIts share under supplementary member
2020Labour, 4650.0%54.2%60.0%
2023National, 4338.1%39.3%52.5%
2026National, 4229.2%32.1%46.7%

In 2023 National would have governed alone with 63 of 120 seats on 38.1 percent of the party vote. In 2020 Labour would have held 72 seats. The rule does not favour one party by name. It favours the biggest party in the electorates, which was Labour in 2020 and National in 2023 and 2026.

The politicians we found proposing it since the election are all from National.

Voters have been asked before

Supplementary member was on the ballot paper in the 1992 referendum, where it drew about 5.5 percent, and again in 2011, when 57.8 percent of voters chose to keep MMP. Mr Smith said on Q+A that he doubts New Zealanders want so large a change, and expects them to prefer adjustments to MMP.

Repair or replace

Supplementary member and our fix start from the same problem: the two votes can be turned against each other. Supplementary member settles it in favour of the electorate vote and gives up a proportional Parliament. Our fix settles it in favour of the party vote: every electorate keeps the MP it chose, and each party gets exactly the votes in Parliament its party vote earned.

One replaces MMP. The other repairs it.

How we checked

  • 2026 figures are from the election-night count and may change when the official results are declared on 27 November 2026. The 2020 and 2023 figures are the Electoral Commission’s official results (2020, 2023).
  • For supplementary member we kept the electorates as they were won and shared out the remaining seats of 120 by party vote, using the same formula and threshold as today. For 2023 we used the 71 electorates decided on election day.
  • These are worked examples, not forecasts. People would vote differently under different rules. Other versions, such as 60 electorates and 60 list seats, would need new boundaries and cannot be worked out from votes already cast.
  • What the politicians said is given in our own words, from the broadcasts and articles linked above. Follow the links for their own words.

Have we got something wrong? Send us a message and we will correct it.